Chapter 152
Aiden
“Leaving? You’re leaving me?” His voice cracked on the word. “No! That’ll do nothing! Even if I was willing to throw any blame on you—which I’m not, no matter what, like, not ever—my face and voice are in that video too. Clearly and horny as fuck, enjoying your attention.”
God, he didn’t understand. I wished he didn’t sound so damn certain, so defiant, because it made what I was about to do ten times harder.
“I can make sure no one judges you for it,” I told him quietly. “I’ll twist the truth enough that it’ll look like something else. Something… I forced on you.”
The shock in his eyes hit like a slap. “You did not fucking force me! Jesus, Aiden, we talked about this!” He shot to his feet, his voice rising.
I kept my tone level. Calm. Detached. It was the only way I could keep from falling apart. “Noah, I’m a thirty-five-year-old failure who’s already blown through half his chances. I’ve made mistakes I can’t take back, and this one—this one’s mine to fix. But you… You’ve got a shot at something real, Noah. Not just to stand with the great—but to rise above every one of them. Don’t throw that away.”
He shook his head, anger flashing bright and raw. “Don’t do that. Don’t act like your life’s over. You’re fucking incredible, Aiden! You inspired me to quit being a screw-up.”
“I manipulated you into not being one,” I said. “I used my position. I broke every rule that was supposed to protect you.”
“Don’t you dare say you regret what we had.”
“I’m not sorry,” I snapped before I could stop myself. The word cracked the air between us, honest and ugly.
He froze, caught off guard by the rawness in my voice.
“I should be,” I went on, softer now, staring at the floor because I couldn’t bear his eyes on me. “But I’m not. I’m not good enough to regret it. You were good for me, Noah. Maybe the best thing that ever happened to me. But it can’t last.”
His jaw tightened. “So what, you’re just gonna take the blame and set me free? That’s your fix?”
“It’s my choice,” I said, lifting my gaze to him. “Not yours.”
“The hell it is!” he threw back. “I won’t let you do this!”
I almost smiled. That stubbornness—his refusal to give up—was one of the thousand reasons I loved him. And that was exactly why I had to break him now.
“So what’s your alternative?” I asked, voice steady but my pulse thrumming. “You want to fake it for the rest of your life? Smile for cameras, play house, pretend you’re straight while the whole world watches?”
He looked at me with something close to desperation. “I never had to fake it with you. Why can’t we just—”
“What, Noah?” I cut in. “Why can’t we just tell the world? Announce that the college coach’s been screwing his much younger player and hope they clap for us? Hope the NFL hands you a trophy instead of a suspension and the board congratulates me instead of marching me out with security before the ink on my termination’s dry? Or do you rather us hide and fuck in bathrooms while you sleep at home with your wife? That’s not a life I want for either of us.”
His breath hitched, and I could see the fight draining out of him. He looked younger suddenly. Lost.
What I didn’t say was that he was the only thing I’d ever truly wanted—and that I was destroying us to save him. That if I had to play the villain, the predator, the monster they already thought I was to keep him safe, then so be it.
It wasn’t fair. But then, nothing about loving him ever was.
He stood in front of me, shoulders tense, eyes wet and blazing. “You think I’d mind coming out?” he said. “The only reason I haven’t told the whole damn world about us is you. You, Aiden. I did this to protect you, not me.”
I swallowed hard. “And what about your family?” My voice came rougher than I meant it to. “You still have them to think about. Their safety depends on your future. Have you forgotten why you started this in the first place?”
He shook his head, breathing hard. “Then what’s left for me? You want me to just move on? Pretend none of this happened? I’d rather sneak around in bathrooms the rest of my life than lose you completely.” His throat worked, his voice breaking. “Please… don’t go. Don’t leave me.”
The words hit deeper than I wanted them to. For a second, all I wanted to do was pull him close and tell him that I wasn’t going anywhere—that we could still find a way. But I couldn’t. Not when every direction we turned meant destroying him.
He stared at me, waiting, trembling between anger and heartbreak when I said nothing. “I guess it was stupid,” he said quietly, “thinking I could marry Lexie and still keep you. I didn’t realize that being with you was never really an option.”
I looked away and finished the rest of my drink, the burn doing nothing to drown the ache. I could feel him watching me, waiting for something that wasn’t coming. And God, I hated myself for letting him believe— even for a minute—that I didn’t want him.
He exhaled sharply. “Is this because of that Micah? You’re back with him, so now you don’t want me? You don’t want to fight for us?”
I forced myself to meet his eyes. “Micah’s easy,” I said. “He’s calm. Safe. He’s not tangled in all of this. With him, there’s no risk, no press, no goddamn blackmail.” I paused, hating every word even as I said it. “It was selfish of me to drag you into this mess. I don’t regret loving you, Noah. But if taking the blame means you walk away clean—means I get to breathe again—then maybe that’s what I deserve. To finally live without fear. Away from all of this. Away from you.”
I watched the anger flash across his face—the humiliation, the hurt—and it almost broke me. But I had to let him hate me. Hate was safer than love right now.
He turned for the door, shoulders shaking, then spun back one last time, voice rough. “If you don’t want me, then why the hell do you care if I marry her?”
I took a breath, steadying myself. “Because I don’t want to see your life ruined,” I said quietly. “By anyone. Not even me.”
His eyes hardened. “With all due respect,” he said, voice trembling with fury, “fuck you, Aiden.”
The door slammed behind him, and I just stood there, listening to the echo fade—knowing it was the sound of everything I’d just lost.