Chapter 134
Noah
The last few days before Christmas felt like a movie I hadn’t agreed to star in.
Lexie threw herself into every glittering plan—family dinners, the tree lighting, the endless laughter that filled every room of that house. Her joy was real, and watching it hurt in ways I couldn’t explain. She was kind, bright, the kind of girl who deserved everything soft in the world. And I was a lie wrapped in a smile.
Two days before Christmas, she surprised me with a day trip to Aspen. “It’ll be fun,” she said, her eyes shining. “Just you and me.”
And she was right—at least on paper. The streets looked like a freaking Christmas card, snow falling in lazy spirals, carols drifting from open shop doors. We stopped for cocoa, bought ornaments, rode a carousel that made her laugh like a kid. For a few hours, I could almost forget who I was. I mean, who the hell wouldn't want this?
Perfect girl, her adoring family—William aside, money, success, beauty… I could've loved this too, but when she leaned over on the horse-drawn carriage and kissed me, soft and sudden, my heart sank.
I’d been dodging any real contact for days—polite distance, the excuse of family around us—but this time there was nowhere to go. Her lips were warm, trembling, hopeful.
I kissed her back because I couldn’t stand to hurt her.
Dinner came next, at a charming little inn strung with twinkle lights and mistletoe. And when she told me we’d be staying the night, alone, I realized there was no way out without breaking her heart.
She’d thought of everything—fireplace, music, a bottle of wine waiting. It was perfect. Too perfect.
“Let’s go in the hot tub,” she said at some point with a grin. “Can you undo my zipper?”
Fuck.
She turned around, gathering her hair over one shoulder, and I reached for the delicate line of metal down her back. The sound of it lowering was soft, almost intimate. Her dress slid to the floor in a sigh of fabric, pooling around her feet like spilled light. Thank God she was wearing a tiny white bikini underneath—one mercy I hadn’t earned.
We stepped into the steaming water, the cold night air biting at our shoulders as snow fell in lazy flakes outside. She leaned back against the edge, eyes half-closed, her smile reflecting the glow of the floating lights. I tried. I smiled, toasted, laughed where I was supposed to. She moved closer until her knee brushed mine under the water, until her voice came softer.
“I just want to thank you,” she whispered. “For being here. For being mine. I love you, Noah.”
Her words ached. I said, “I love you too,” because it felt like it was the nice thing to say—as I tried not to think of the man who owned those words first.
When she leaned in, her arms slid around my neck, her voice a soft rush against my ear. “I know this has been stressful for you, and I’m so grateful. My dad can be a bit… intense.”
If by intense you mean a manipulative bastard…
“And Christmas with my whole family can be a lot,” she added with a nervous laugh, her fingers tracing slow circles on my shoulder. “But I want you to know how much I appreciate you. How much I want you.”
She kissed my neck, gentle at first, then with a kind of hunger that made my pulse jump for all the wrong reasons. I froze. This—this was the one thing I hadn’t agreed to. I could fake the smiles, the charm, the part of the doting boyfriend. But not this. My cock refused to lie for me.
She was beautiful—God, she was perfect—but it didn’t matter. Nothing in me responded. Not to her almost naked body, her warmth against me, her perfect boobs pressing against my chest… All I could think about was the man who’d ruined me for anyone else. The one whose voice still echoed in my head when I closed my eyes.
In the past I would’ve been all over her—kissing every inch of that soft skin, salivating and needing no encouragement from any Hart senior to court, date or fuck his sexy daughter.
But since Aiden… his touch, his voice, his hard cock riding me raw, his powerful arms around my body, owning me like I belonged nowhere else… there was no one else who could compare.
The ghost of it burned through me now, cruel and real, while Lexie’s soft hands tried to summon something I didn’t have left to give.
When she kissed me harder, I tried to keep up, to be kind, to not make her feel unwanted. She whispered that there was no one there to see, that I was hers, that she loved me. I wanted to believe that pretending could make it easier, but it only made it worse.
Before I knew it, her bikini was gone, and oblivious to the war in my head, she took my hand and led me out of the hot tub, guiding me to the thick heated carpet across from the fireplace.
I didn’t encourage her but couldn’t stop her either. The moment her warm lips brushed against my skin, trailing small kisses from my chest to my groin, I closed my eyes, feeling as if it was Aiden’s mouth closing around my cock.
“Hell yeah, babe,” I moaned, as liquid heat enveloped the head of my cock. “Fuck, I missed your mouth…”
I instinctively fisted her hair, bucking my hips and launching straight into Lexie’s throat. When she released my cock with a gasp and our eyes finally met, my heart skipped a beat—the spell suddenly broken.
Fuck, what have I done? And what the fuck is wrong with me…? My chest ached with longing and guilt.
She wasn’t Aiden and this wasn’t right.
“Shit!” I practically jumped off the bed. “I’m so sorry, Lexie…”
“Is everything okay?” Her sweetness turned to confusion, then quiet hurt. Finally, she looked away, her voice breaking. “Did I do something wrong?”
And all I could do was shake my head, the words catching in my throat. “No. It’s me. I’m sorry—I just… I can’t.”
Her silence was heavier than any shout. I sat there, breathing hard, wishing I could explain the mess I’d become—the truth that every part of me already belonged to someone else.
The ride back to the estate was a blur of awkward silence and practiced smiles. Lexie leaned against the window, humming along to the radio, her hand resting over my arm like we were any normal couple driving home from a perfect night. I kept my eyes on the road, as I drove her father's car, pretending I didn’t feel the weight in the air.
That afternoon, I did my best to breathe again. Made a few calls to my family, answered messages, told myself that this—this quiet—was peace. At least for a few hours, I was being left alone as the women worked organising last minute details before our Christmas eve’s celebration.
The entire thing was nuts. How the hell had I gotten into this? The guy who ran from home to be free and ended up in another prison…
It felt good to breathe for a moment. To talk to my people, to feel at ease.
So when William appeared at the doorway of the den, smiling like the perfect host, I almost rolled my eyes.
What now?
“Hi, son,” he said, voice smooth as glass. “Can we speak for a moment?”
I followed him down the hall to his office, past the rows of framed photos and trophies gleaming in the morning light. For a split second, I thought maybe he was going to show me his cigar collection, give me another task, another line to memorize in the story of us.
The moment the door clicked shut behind me, his smile vanished.
Before I could breathe, his hand was on my throat, slamming me back against the wall. The world tilted, air cutting off as his fingers tightened.
“Who the fuck do you think you are?” he hissed.