Chapter 123

Noah

I hadn’t made it halfway down the hall before William Hart blocked my path, sliding in front of me with that practiced ease of a man who always got what he wanted.

“Noah,” he said, all warmth and polish. “Great game tonight. I didn’t want to embarrass you in front of the others, but let’s be honest—you were the star out there.”

I forced a grin. “Thank you, sir. It was really teamwork.” My voice sounded steady, but inside I could feel the adrenaline still buzzing, the kind that made it hard to tell if he was complimenting me or cornering me.

“I understand that, son, but I’m sure you know these men were here for you, right? Have you thought about my proposition?” His tone was smooth, measured, the way people talk when they’re sure they’ve already won.

And there it was. The real reason. The handshake and small talk had only been the preamble.

“I really appreciate your kind offer, Mr. Hart, but Coach Aiden just connected me with three major scouts, and they’re willing to—”

“Noah,” he cut in smoothly, “what your coach can offer are possibilities in the long run. What I’m offering is already within your reach.” His smile didn’t falter, but the edge in his words pressed harder, like a deal sliding across the table with a price tag attached.

“It’s incredibly tempting, but I just wouldn’t feel comfortable,” I said carefully, forcing each word out like I was picking my way across a minefield.

“I don’t quite understand.” His brow went up, polished charm never cracking, but the look in his eyes said he understood plenty—he just didn’t like my answer.

“Well, sir, I know Lexie and I have been hanging out, and I didn’t want anyone—especially you—to think it had anything to do with…” I trailed, wishing I could vanish before I put my foot further in my mouth.

“Noah, it’s no secret my daughter is fond of you. I want her to be happy, of course. But let’s be clear—I believe you’re an extraordinary player, and I don’t see why we can’t all win here. You’re happy, she’s happy, and I get to invest in a true champion.” William shrugged like it was the most reasonable thing in the world. “A player of your caliber doesn’t just need to shine on the field—he needs to shine everywhere. Image matters, Noah. Reputation matters. With your talent and my influence, and someone like Lexie by your side, you’d be unstoppable. You’d have the whole package, the kind of brand even the pros dream about.”

“But Mr. Hart, Lexie and I aren’t dating.” My voice came out firmer than I meant. “I can’t really commit to her that way.”

“Oh, forgive me for insinuating, Noah. I must’ve been under a different impression. You two certainly look close.” His smile didn’t quite reach his eyes, and the pause after was loaded.

“We are! She’s incredible,” I added quickly, the words tumbling out before I could stop them. And it was true—Lexie was incredible—but the guilt gnawed deeper knowing I’d let things look like more than they were.

William tilted his head, studying me with something sharper than curiosity. “I don’t mean to pry, but… are you seeing someone else then?”

Nosy much? The thought came bitter, but I didn’t dare let it show.

“No, sir, it’s not that—I just can’t commit to anyone right now. I’ve got way too much going on.” The words tumbled out, but inside I knew it wasn’t just about “too much going on.” It was about secrets I couldn’t share and a truth I couldn’t afford him even sniffing at.

As we neared the table again, he patted my shoulder with that politician’s grin. “You could have a lot more going on with a lot less hassle. Maybe then you’d have time for the things that really matter, Blake. Think about it.” His hand lingered a second longer than necessary, as if to drive the point home—an offer, a warning, and a claim all at once.

The party was loud and warm, buzzing with too many eyes and too much pressure. William and a couple of other big shots stuck around, drinks in hand, letting the team circle them like moths to a flame. Every guy wanted his chance—showing off highlight reels on their phones, dropping stats, and talking dreams like they were selling themselves at an auction.

Me? I downed another drink just to take the edge off, telling myself it was nerves and not weakness. Didn’t matter. The burn was better than the knot in my chest.

Lexie’s friends kept orbiting us, squealing, nudging, and tossing not-so-subtle hints about how “cute” we were. Every time they said it, Lexie’s face went redder. She tried to laugh it off and even threw me a couple apologetic looks across the circle like ‘kill me now.’ I laughed along, pretending I was in on the joke. Didn’t want to make it awkward.

Finally, when her dad drifted toward another cluster of suits, Lexie tugged my sleeve and steered me away from the noise.

“I’m sorry about my friends,” she muttered, cheeks still flushed. “They don’t get that we’re not—”

I cut her off with a crooked smile. “Don’t sweat it. My friends are the same way. They don’t get it either.”

She huffed a little laugh, looking at me sideways. “Okay, also… about earlier, when you talked to my dad, was he being… pushy? Or overly enthusiastic? I know he can be.”

I just smiled, noncommittal. “He means well. He’s really trying to help. And looking out for you too.”

Her eyes widened. “Oh God… I hope he wasn’t talking to you about me.”

I shook my head but didn’t answer, because yeah, that was exactly what had happened. And standing there, tipsy enough for the truth to sting sharper, I felt the weight of the whole charade pressing down on her too. The way I’d led her on at first, half to cover my own ass, half to score points with her dad. The way I’d reeled it back into just friends once I had what I wanted—while she still had to deal with her feelings and all the whispers about us being some golden couple. She hadn’t asked for any of it.

“Hey,” I said softly, trying to make it easier on her. “It’s okay. Really. You don’t have to feel uncomfortable. I was the one who led people on. I made it look like more than it was.”

I made it look exactly like what I wanted her and everyone else to believe… I could be such an asshole.

In my pocket, my phone buzzed, and all I could think about was Aiden’s reward and how much I missed him. That pull toward him—dangerous, undeniable—was stronger than the noise of the party or the weight of anyone’s attention.

But deep down, I knew it couldn’t always be about me. And I had no idea that the next time I reached for that phone, it wouldn’t save me—it would ruin me.