Chapter 14: Before the Fall

The tears had slowed, but neither of them moved.

The city buzzed faintly outside the window—car horns, distant laughter, the hum of traffic below. But inside the apartment, time felt suspended.

Eva exhaled shakily and said, barely above a whisper, “You know I met him because of a lost coffee order?”

Rachel blinked, surprised. “No. You never told me.”

Eva leaned back against the couch, eyes glassy but soft now. “It was two years ago. At that little café on East 12th—the one with the crooked tables and the barista who never smiled?”

“Oh my God, I remember that place,” Rachel said, scooting in closer.

Eva gave a faint laugh. “Yeah. So I’d ordered a black Americano and was waiting for it. And then this guy steps up, grabs a coffee that clearly wasn’t his, and takes a sip. Immediately makes this awful face—like someone had poisoned him.”

Rachel smirked. “That sounds right.”

“I told him he’d taken mine, and instead of apologizing, he just said, ‘You drink this on purpose?’ Like I was personally offending his taste buds.”

Rachel laughed. “What did you do?”

“I rolled my eyes, obviously. And he said, ‘Let me make it up to you—sit with me. I’ll convince you to add cream.’”

Eva smiled at the memory, eyes going distant.

“He had this annoying grin. Like he knew I’d say yes.”

“And did you?”

“I told him I had five minutes,” Eva said softly. “We ended up sitting there for two hours.”

\---

Flashback — Two Years Ago

The coffee shop was half-empty, sunlight spilling across the mismatched furniture. Eva sat across from the cocky stranger with the too-bright smile and the sleeves of his henley pushed to his elbows.

“So,” he said, swirling his own drink, “why the masochism? Straight black? What happened to you?”

Eva arched a brow. “What happened to you that you think hazelnut syrup is acceptable after age fifteen?”

He laughed, warm and unguarded.

And just like that, something clicked.

It wasn’t fireworks or fate.

It was easy.

Like finding a familiar song you forgot you loved.

They talked about bad movies and worse dates, about cities they wanted to live in and books they hadn’t finished. He asked questions—real ones—and listened like the answers mattered.

She left the café that day with her phone buzzing.

> Noah: In case you change your mind about cream.

Also, I want to see you again.

\---

Present Day

Eva’s voice was quieter now. “He didn’t kiss me that day. Just walked me to the corner, waited for my cab, and told me I had a laugh that sounded like trouble.”

Rachel rested her head gently on Eva’s shoulder. “You did love him.”

“I still do,” Eva whispered. “That’s the worst part.”

They sat there, tangled in memory, in silence

Not in hope.

Not in closure.

Just memory.

Warm and aching and rea

Rachel didn’t say anything right away.

She just stayed there, shoulder to shoulder with Eva, as the weight of old feelings pulled them both into silence.

Eva brushed a tear from her cheek with the back of her hand. “I think part of me thought we were inevitable. Like no matter how bad it got, we’d find our way back.”

Rachel hesitated. “Do you still believe that?”

Eva stared at the ceiling for a moment. “I don’t know what I believe anymore.”

There was a pause.

Then she added, “But I do know this—what I saw that night wasn’t him. Not the version I met. Not the one I fell for.”

Rachel leaned forward. “So which one are you mourning?”

Eva swallowed hard. “Both.”

\---

Later that night, Eva stood in front of her bedroom mirror, clutching an old photo she hadn’t looked at in months.

It was one Rachel had snapped on a random Sunday—Eva and Noah in the kitchen, mid-laugh, flour on his shirt and frosting on her cheek. They looked messy. Happy. Young.

She stared at it for a long time.

Then she slipped it into the drawer and closed it gently.

Some memories didn’t need to be erased.

But they didn’t belong on display anymore

either.