Chapter 29: Caught

I wake up sore. It’s a deep, throbbing kind of pain that starts in my shins and radiates up to my hips. My legs feel heavy, like they’ve been replaced by lead pipes, and muscles I never even knew I had are screaming in protest. Last night at the rink was beautiful, but my body is paying the price for every stumble and every desperate save Jaxson made to keep me upright.

Before I can even pull the covers over my head to hide from the morning light, my phone buzzes on the nightstand. The vibration rattles against the wood, sending a jolt of adrenaline through me. I grab it, squinting at the bright screen.

JAXSON: How are the legs? Mine are fine, but my heart is still racing. Tell me you dreamt of me.

I smile, a goofy, helpless thing that makes my cheeks ache. I fall back against my pillow, staring at the ceiling and clutching the phone to my chest.

"Maya! Get up! You'll be late for the service!"

My mom’s voice cuts through my daydream like a siren. I can hear the clatter of plates in the kitchen—the sound of a Sunday morning in the flats. I shove my phone under my pillow, heart hammering. If Leo or my mom found those texts, the world would end before breakfast was over. I roll out of bed, wincing as my stiff muscles protest, and run for a quick, scalding shower to wash the smell of the rink and the anxiety away.

When I finally step outside, the entire neighborhood feels still. Sunday is the only time this place truly quiets down. The usual background noise of the flats—the screaming sirens, the clanking of wrenches in the garages, the bass-heavy music from the corner store—is gone. It’s replaced by a heavy, reverent hush. The only sound is the rhythmic, deep tolling of the bell at St. Jude’s, calling the broken and the hopeful to the pews.

A few minutes later, I’m standing in the church vestibule. The air inside is cool and smells of melted wax and old, polished wood. I smooth out the wrinkles in my only good dress—a simple navy thing that hits just above my knees—and reach up to touch the silver butterfly charm.

I scan the room, expecting to see the usual faces. I see Mrs. Gable in her floral hat, the tired mothers trying to keep their toddlers quiet, and Leo. Leo is usually already inside, tucked into the back pew with a scowl on his face, looking like he’d rather be under a car chassis than under a roof of prayer.

The corner of my eyes catches a black sedan idling at the far end of the gravel parking lot. My breath hitches. I know that car. And then, standing near the side entrance in the shadow of the stone archway, I see him. A tall, broad-shouldered figure looking completely out of place. He’s wearing a dark suit jacket and a crisp white shirt, his hair pushed back and tidy. He looks like a prince who took a wrong turn and ended up in the slums.

"Jaxson?" I whisper, stepping into the shadows to join him. My heart is beating so hard I can see the butterfly charm trembling.

He turns nervously fiddling with his cuffs, his eyes darting toward the church doors as if he expects a bolt of lightning to strike him down.

"You go to church?" I ask, my eyes wide.

He offers a small, crooked smile that doesn't quite reach his eyes. "My grandmother used to take me to the cathedral in the city before she passed. I haven't been in years, but... I don't know."

He looks up at the worn stone steps and the peeling paint of the church door. "There’s a lot about me you don't know yet, Maya Vance."

"Clearly," I breathe, my chest tightening. Every time I think I have him figured out, he shows me another layer, another reason to fall.

I reach into my small velvet purse, my fingers brushing against the gift I’ve been carrying around like a hot coal. "I have something for you. I know it’s... it’s nothing like the necklace. I know the price doesn't even come close, but I saw it and thought of you. I was going to wait until Monday at school, but after last night... I want you to have it now."

I hand him a small, worn leather pouch. His large hand swallows it as he carefully pulls the drawstring. Inside is a vintage brass compass I found at the flea market months ago. I’d spent hours polishing it with an old rag until the brass shone like gold. On the back, I’d had a local jeweler engrave four simple words in delicate script: Find your own way.

Jaxson takes it out, his large thumb tracing the engraving over and over. He stays silent for a long time, his throat bobbing as he swallows hard.

"I love it, Maya," he whispers, his voice cracking.

"You don't have to lie, Jax. It’s just an old piece of metal compared to the things you’re used to—"

"No one has ever given me a gift before," he interrupts, his voice thick and raw. "Not like this. My dad gives me checks or keys to cars. Chloe gives me things she thinks I should wear so I look better in her photos. But this... no one has ever given me something just because they knew what I was thinking."

He steps closer, the scent of his expensive cologne mixing with the faint, dusty smell of incense drifting from the open doors. He takes my hand in his, his skin warm and rough against my knuckles, tracing the bone with his thumb.

He leans in, his shadow falling over me, his eyes dropping to my lips. He’s about to kiss me—really kiss me, right here on holy ground—when a voice like a thunderclap forces us apart.

"Maya!"

The voice doesn't come from the pews. It comes from the heavy oak doors at the front of the church, echoing with a violence that makes the birds scatter from the belfry.

Leo is standing there, looking at us.