Chapter 178: Chapter 177
Harper POV
I make it three days before I break.
Three days of pretending I’m okay.
Three days of avoiding the rink.
Avoiding Logan.
Avoiding everything that reminds me of him.
Which turns out to be impossible.
Because Logan is everywhere now.
In hockey posters around campus.
In whispers from girls in my biology lecture.
In the coffee shop where he used to steal drinks from me and grin when I got annoyed.
Even the cold air outside reminds me of him now.
Everything does.
And somehow?
Instead of getting easier—
It’s getting worse.
Lila watches me push cereal around my bowl for almost five full minutes before finally speaking.
“You know starvation isn’t technically heartbreak therapy.”
“I’m eating.”
“You’ve moved one Cheerio for emotional support.”
I glare weakly at her.
“I’m tired.”
“No,” she says carefully. “You’re miserable.”
Fair.
I drop the spoon back into the bowl with a quiet clink.
Because honestly?
I don’t even have the energy to argue anymore.
The last few days feel blurry.
Like I’m walking through life underwater while trying not to think too hard about the fact that I told the person I love goodbye for his own good.
And the worst part?
I still don’t know if it was the right thing.
That uncertainty is killing me slowly.
My phone buzzes against the table.
My entire body reacts instantly before I can stop it.
Lila notices.
Of course she does.
“You still hoping it’s him?”
“No.”
Lie.
Complete lie.
I look down.
Not Logan.
Cole.
My stomach twists immediately.
That can’t be good.
I open the message.
Need to talk to you.
Cold dread crawls slowly down my spine.
Because nobody sends a message like that unless something’s wrong.
And suddenly panic starts building fast in my chest.
Before I can answer—
Another message comes through.
It’s about Logan.
My heart drops violently.
I’m already standing before I fully realize I moved.
Lila looks alarmed immediately.
“What happened?”
“I don’t know.”
But deep down?
I think I do.
⸻
I find Cole outside the rink twenty minutes later.
The second I see his face—
My stomach sinks.
Because he looks worried.
Actually worried.
Not annoyed.
Not judgmental.
Worried.
And suddenly I can barely breathe.
“What happened?” I ask immediately.
Cole exhales slowly.
“He’s running himself into the ground.”
Pain slices straight through my chest.
“What?”
“He’s barely sleeping. Staying after practice for hours.” Cole shakes his head slightly. “Coach found him alone at the rink after midnight.”
Oh God.
The world tilts slightly beneath me.
“No.”
“He’s playing insane hockey right now,” Cole continues quietly. “But it’s not healthy.”
Tears sting my eyes instantly.
Because no.
No no no.
This was supposed to help him.
I left so things would settle.
So he could breathe again.
So hockey would come first naturally again.
But instead—
“He looks worse,” Cole admits softly.
The words shatter something inside me.
I physically take a step backward.
“No.”
It comes out broken.
Weak.
Like maybe if I say it enough times reality changes.
Cole’s expression softens immediately.
“I’m sorry.”
My chest hurts.
Actually hurts.
Because suddenly I realize the truth.
Leaving didn’t save him.
It just hurt both of us.
I press my hand hard against my mouth trying to hold myself together.
“This wasn’t supposed to happen.”
“I know.”
“I thought…” My voice cracks violently. “I thought if I stepped away he’d go back to himself.”
Cole is quiet for a second.
Then carefully—
“I don’t think there’s a version of him that goes back anymore.”
That completely destroys me.
The tears come hard and immediate now.
Because deep down?
I already knew.
Logan changed me too.
There’s no going backward for either of us now.
“He still loves you,” Cole says quietly.
I let out a broken laugh through the tears.
“That’s the problem.”
Silence settles heavily between us.
The rink looms behind him while students pass nearby completely unaware my entire world feels like it’s collapsing inward.
“He’s turning hockey into punishment,” Cole says finally. “Like he’s trying to skate hard enough not to feel anything.”
My eyes close briefly.
Because I know Logan.
I know exactly what that means.
If he’s hurting?
He pushes harder.
If he’s angry?
He trains harder.
If he’s breaking?
He hides it inside hockey.
And suddenly Coach’s words from before echo in my head.
He looked exhausted.
Oh God.
This is my fault.
“No,” Cole says immediately like he can read my mind. “Don’t do that.”
“But—”
“This didn’t start with you.”
I wipe at my face shakily.
“Then why does it feel like I’m watching him destroy himself because of me?”
Cole’s jaw tightens slightly.
“Because his father got into both your heads.”
That lands hard.
Because it’s true.
Every fear.
Every doubt.
Every horrible thought that maybe loving each other was dangerous—
It all started there.
With pressure.
Manipulation.
Fear.
And now we’re both drowning in it.
“I don’t know what to do anymore,” I whisper.
Cole studies me carefully.
Then quietly—
“Do you wanna know what Coach said?”
My breathing catches slightly.
“What?”
“He told Logan he was happier with you.”
Everything inside me stills.
“What?”
Cole nods once.
“He said yeah, Logan got distracted sometimes. But he also looked alive.”
Alive.
The word hits me directly in the heart.
Because lately?
Logan hasn’t looked alive at all.
He’s looked angry.
Exhausted.
Empty.
The exact version of himself I was trying to prevent.
And suddenly the horrible truth crashes over me all at once.
Maybe I was trying so hard to save Logan’s future—
That I forgot to save Logan himself.
The realization nearly buckles my knees.
“Harper.”
I shake my head quickly.
“I don’t know how to fix this.”
Cole exhales slowly.
“Honestly? I don’t think either of you do right now.”
Great.
Fantastic.
Exactly what I wanted to hear.
“But,” he says carefully, “I think you both stopped fighting the actual problem.”
I look up slowly.
“What do you mean?”
“His father,” Cole says bluntly. “The pressure. The expectations. The idea that Logan has to choose between being successful and being human.”
Silence crashes heavily between us.
Because suddenly—
That’s it.
That’s the real issue underneath everything.
Not love.
Fear.
Logan was taught his entire life that emotions make him weak.
That hockey comes first.
That anything threatening focus gets cut away.
Including people.
Including me.
And somewhere along the way—
We started believing it too.
Tears slide quietly down my face again.
Because I still don’t know what the right answer is.
I still don’t know if loving Logan eventually hurts him.
But one thing is suddenly horribly clear.
Leaving him didn’t save him after all.
And honestly?
That realization scares me more than staying ever did.