Chapter 28: A Choice

Scarlett’s Point of View

I drew a ragged breath, my lungs constricting. This has to be a joke; he can't punish me so severely. I'd rather die than be the one to kill one of my parents.

“Asher, please don't make me do this.” My voice broke, my words barely audible. This was the cruelest punishment I'd ever endured in my entire life, and for something I had no idea about.

Asher stared at me blankly, devoid of emotions in his eyes, and I knew how serious he must be. “You have thirty seconds to make a decision before I make it for you.” His tone was stern.

Hot tears streamed down my cheeks, their warmth spreading across my face. My whole body shook with sobs that I tried to hold back. How could I possibly kill my own parents, no matter how bad they are?

How could one have the strength to do it?

“Scarlett, if you dare to kill me, you'll be sent to jail. Don't forget what you did. Once I'm dead, my men will send the evidence to the police, and you will rot in jail.” My mother's tone was now stern and threatening, sending a sharp pang cutting through my chest. It was too unbearable.

“Scarlett, I've raised you and made you what you are today. Do you have the guts to kill me after everything?” My father's voice dripped with sarcasm, fear etched on his face but masked with sarcasm.

Here I was begging for their life, but they thought it was the best idea to blackmail me.

A hollow ache spread through my cheek. I tried to breathe, but my lungs constricted, my whole body numb. I couldn't feel myself.

“Twenty seconds left.” Asher's stern voice brought me back to reality. I had to make my decision right now, no matter how painful it was. My hands trembled as I picked up the gun on the ground, tears streaming down my cheeks like a non-stop flowing river. At this point, all my emotions were completely numb, all I could do was cry.

“Asher…” I stammered between my sobs. “Why are you punishing me? I haven't wronged you in any way. I know I lied to you about my identity, and I'm sorry for it. Other than that, what have I done to you that you'll punish me so harshly?”

Asher let out a cold chuckle, his eyes stern and cold. “You are not as foolish as I thought. Good thing you've figured out your mistakes.”He shot back. “Had you told me the truth earlier, all this wouldn't have happened. But now you will pay for your sister’s mistake, and you'd wish for death every day of your life.” A chill of dread ran down my spine as Asher’s words sank in. This only means he knew the truth from the beginning and now was going to punish me even when I haven't wronged him.

“Scarlett, if you shoot me, then it would confirm that you indeed had feelings for Asher. I'd know that you are glad that your sister is dead so you'd have her husband.” My mother's words echoed in my ears, piercing right into my soul.

I'd never fallen in love with Asher, even in my wildest dreams, nor was I glad that Scarlynn was dead, leaving me to clean up all her mess. I was paying for her sins while she must be resting wherever she is.

“You've been a whore since you were young, and your actions today will simply prove it. I won't be shocked if you decide to shoot me.” I threw a pained look at my father, more tears welling up in my eyes. He was my dad, I loved him just like how I loved my mom, but they never considered me to be their own. It has always been about Scarlynn. Everyone cared more about her, and she was always the center of attention.

They never actually noticed me, no matter how much effort I put in. They never cared, and now I had to choose between them.

My hands trembled as I pulled the trigger, and the echo of the gunshot reverberated inside the silent room. I burst into sobs as blood gushed out of my father's chest, his eyes locked into mine. His disappointment stared right at me as his body rested on the chair.

“You've always been selfish, Scarlett.” He stammered before his eyes finally shut closed, a pang of remorse echoing through my chest.

He was right. I've always been the selfish one. Had I not been selfish, I could have just shot myself instead of either of them. But how could I have left little Asherly alone? She deserves love, attention, care, and a mother who loves her, and I'm selfish for choosing her over my father.

“I hope you are happy with yourself for murdering my husband.” My mother's tone dripped with bitterness.

Numbness spread through my whole body. I just didn't know how to feel. I just…

I burst into sobs, my screams filling the room, this was too much for me and I couldn't bear it at all.

“Take her away.” I could hear Asher talking, but his words fell on deaf ears. The guards dragged me out of the basement, and I didn't even realize when they had thrown me inside the car and drove off.

I was sure of one thing: I won't ever be the same after this. A part of me was dead. I'd drown back into my past, and nothing will ever save me. It'd be only me and my demons and darkness. There won't be any rays of sunshine. There won't be anything that can ever bring me out of it.

I desperately wanted someone to tell me that it was all a dream and wake me up from this terrible nightmare. But it was unfortunately my reality, the worst reality of my life. At this point, I wish I had died before I was even born. What was the reason for my existence? Was this the reason to suffer to this extent? It was all too unbearable, and I'd just pray that I won't murder Asher Black. I've already murdered more than I should, and I didn't want it to become my new addiction.