Chapter 83

Inside, the apartment felt far too quiet. Katherine leaned her back against the door long after the final lock had clicked into place. Her hands were trembling, her heart thundering beneath her ribcage like it wanted to claw its way out and run to him.

She sank to the floor slowly, drawing her knees up to her chest. Her living room was lit only by a warm lamp in the corner, casting shadows across the photographs on the wall, the couch, and the books stacked on the window sill. The air smelled like lavender and cinnamon from the candle she had burned earlier in the evening.

It should have felt like home. It had felt like home just hours ago.

Now it felt like a fortress. Or a prison.

Because he was outside.

Kingsley.

The man she had once loved with a heart so open it scared her. The man who had broken her. Twice. And the man who, even now, had the audacity to sit outside her door like a penitent knight who’d returned too late to the battle.

She pulled herself up, one hand on the doorframe for balance, and walked slowly to the front window. She moved the curtain just an inch.

And there he was.

Sitting on the top step, hunched slightly, elbows on knees, staring out into the night. The streetlamp down the block cast just enough light to catch his profile—tired, unshaven, hollow-eyed. A duffel bag sat beside him. He hadn’t moved.

Her breath hitched.

She let the curtain fall and turned away too fast, as though she’d been burned.

She went to the kitchen and poured herself a glass of water, but her hand shook too much and some spilled on the counter. She cursed softly, grabbed a paper towel, and wiped it up. Every movement was sharp, annoyed. With him. With herself.

With the truth she didn’t want to face:

Even now, even after everything… a part of her wanted to open that door.

But she couldn’t.

Not after the way it felt to wake up to that photo of him and Beth—her hand on his chest, their bodies so familiar. Not after hearing silence when she needed answers. Not after remembering how easily he’d chosen someone else before.

She took the water to the couch and sat. Stared at the dark TV screen. She didn’t turn it on.

She didn’t sleep.

Hours passed.

The city outside softened into quiet. Cars thinned. Voices grew fewer. A dog barked once. Somewhere, a train passed.

At 1:14 a.m., she stood up again and crossed the room.

She opened the curtain wider this time.

Still there.

Kingsley now sat with his head leaned against the doorframe, one leg stretched down the steps, the other bent. He looked… tired. Cold. Like a boy lost in a story too big for him.

She wondered if he had eaten. If he’d slept at all since flying from Manhattan. If he even knew how ridiculous it was, what he was doing—how reckless, how futile.

But even now, he stayed.

She pressed her forehead to the glass.

“Why are you doing this?” she whispered, her breath fogging the pane.

It hurt to see him there.

It hurt even more to feel her walls cracking.

Because Kingsley had always known how to break through her logic, crawl past her defenses, kneel before her woundedness with something so stupidly pure it disarmed her.

She hated that part of him. She loved that part of him.

And now he was using it again—his silence, his presence, his quiet refusal to give up.

She stepped back.

She paced the apartment.

She whispered, “Don’t fall for this again, Katherine,” over and over like a prayer. Or a plea.

But her feet kept dragging her back to the window.

And Kingsley kept not leaving.

At 2:30 a.m., the wind outside Brooklyn had grown cruel.

It swept along the streets in invisible fists, rattling loose gutters and whispering through the cracks in old windows. Katherine had tried everything—reading, lying in bed, even playing soft music to distract herself—but sleep refused to come. Her mind kept circling, a restless, relentless orbit around the man outside.

She sat up again, pulling her blanket tighter.

Something told her he’d be gone by now. That he would’ve given up, or at least come to his senses. He had no business being here, not after everything. He didn’t deserve her care, her attention, or even a moment more of her pain.

And yet—

She got up, and padded to the window barefoot, her flannel pajama pants brushing the tops of her ankles.

She peeked again.

The sight nearly broke her.

Kingsley was still there.

Still sitting on the steps, his back leaned against the doorframe. But now—now, his shoulders were shaking. Not from sobs. From cold. His hands were tucked under his arms, his chin lowered to his chest, and his whole frame shuddered like someone trying not to freeze.

Katherine’s breath caught in her throat.

“Oh God…” she whispered, stepping back from the window like it had scalded her.

What was wrong with him? Why would he—

She didn’t finish the thought.

Her feet were already moving, crossing the living room in quick steps. She grabbed the soft gray throw blanket from the back of the couch, and yanked the door open—and there he was, right in front of her now. Real. Shivering. Miserable. His eyes barely lifted when the warm light from inside touched his face.

“Katherine…” he breathed.

“Shh,” she snapped. “You’re freezing.”

He didn’t argue.

She stepped out and wrapped the blanket around his shoulders, tight, pulling it close around his chest like a mother might for a stubborn child. Her hands paused when they brushed against the cold fabric of his shirt—damp from the night air. The gesture was automatic. Tender. And infuriatingly familiar.

“Come in,” she said. “Before you turn into an ice sculpture.”

He obeyed without a word.

Inside, the warmth of her small apartment hit him like a second wave. He stood near the door, unsure, awkward beneath the blanket, his face pale and exhausted. She motioned to the couch.

“Sit.”

He lowered himself into the cushions as she moved toward the kitchen, her arms folded tightly across her chest, her jaw clenched. She filled the kettle, set it on the stove, grabbed her favorite mug—the one with tiny yellow lemons painted around the rim—and dropped it in a chamomile tea bag. The kettle whistled. She poured.

Only after she handed the tea to him did she allow herself to really look at his face.

Kingsley’s eyes were red-rimmed. He looked like he hadn’t slept in days and there was a weariness in his expression that made him seem older—frayed at the edges, undone.

He took the mug carefully. “Thank you,” he said softly. “Thank you so much for letting me come in.”

She stood over him, arms still crossed, her voice sharp.

“What is your problem, Kingsley?” she demanded. “What exactly are you trying to prove? What are you doing? What are you hoping to gain from this?”

He looked up at her, fingers wrapped around the warm mug.

“I just want to gain your attention,” he said quietly. “I just want you to listen to me. I came here because I had to. Because I need to explain my side. You weren’t answering my calls, and after everything that happened, I just— I needed you to know the truth.”

Katherine turned away, shaking her head.

“The truth?” she scoffed. “I don’t want to hear your version of the truth. I’ve heard enough lies and edits and carefully chosen silences to last me a lifetime.”

He opened his mouth, but she raised her hand, cutting him off.

“Don’t. Just… don’t.”

She took a slow breath, trying to hold back the tide rising inside her. Anger. Sadness. Confusion. All of it churning too loudly.

“You can sleep here tonight,” she said flatly. “On the couch. Tomorrow morning, you leave. That’s it. I don’t want any conversations. I don’t want any more drama. Just… sleep. Leave. That’s all.”

And before he could answer, before he could say another syllable to soften her resolve, she turned around and walked swiftly down the hallway, into her bedroom.

She closed the door behind her and leaned against it for a long moment, breathing hard.

On the other side of the door, she could hear him take a sip of the tea. She could hear the soft clink of the mug being set down.

She could feel him there, like a ghost sitting in the center of her home, stirring memories she didn’t want.

She slid down onto the floor again, just like she had hours ago, pulled her knees to her chest, and whispered:

“Why won’t you let me forget you?”

And the night stretched on in silence.

Morning crept into Brooklyn with the gentleness of mercy.

Sunlight, pale and gold, slipped through the slats of Katherine’s blinds and painted faint bars of warmth across the wooden floor. Her alarm buzzed faintly on the nightstand—too soft to be jarring, but insistent enough to pull her from the shallows of a dream she could no longer remember.

She stirred slowly, blinking at the ceiling, heavy with the thick silence of yesterday’s memories.

For a moment, she forgot he was here.

Then it returned—Kingsley. On the couch. In her home. Shivering on her steps in the middle of the night like a man without pride or plan.

She sat up and exhaled.

The ache of old feelings lingered in her chest, and for a flicker of a second, she hated how much room he still occupied in her thoughts. But there was no time to indulge in anything today. It was a workday. A café to open. A schedule to keep. Life didn’t stop for heartbreak.

She slipped out of bed and padded into the living room.

There he was.

Kingsley was still asleep, curled on her couch like a boy exiled from some grand kingdom. The gray throw blanket had slipped down to his waist. One arm hung off the couch, fingers grazing the floor. His lips were parted slightly, and his chest rose and fell in a rhythm that looked unfamiliar to him—peace.

Katherine stood there for a moment, arms folded, heart guarded.

Then—wordlessly, almost reluctantly—she walked over and gently adjusted the blanket back up to his shoulders. Her fingertips brushed his shirt, warm now instead of cold, and she pulled away quickly as if it burned.

She didn’t wake him.

Instead, she turned and walked to the bathroom, where she washed up quickly, then dressed in her simple black work trousers and a soft burgundy blouse. Hair tied back. No makeup. Her armor was efficient.

In the kitchen, she moved with a practiced rhythm. Toast, eggs, fresh-cut fruit, a cup of hot black coffee—no cream, no sugar. She made it the way he liked it. It annoyed her that she still remembered.

The plate was set on the table.

Steam curled up from the cup.

She stared at it for a second too long.

Then she pulled a small notepad from the drawer, tore off a sheet, and scribbled with the pen that was always there beside the fridge magnet:

“When you wake up, you can have your breakfast on the table. Then leave before I come back and don't forget to lock the door and leave my key under the foot mat.”

The message was clear—measured kindness, but no invitation for anything more.

She walked over, quietly set the note on the table beside the plate, and turned back toward the door. Her keys jingled faintly as she picked them up, and for a second, she glanced over her shoulder at him again.

Still sleeping.

Still unaware.

Still, the man she used to know—complicated, powerful, devastating.

She opened the door.

A gust of morning air met her cheeks as she stepped out and closed it gently behind her, leaving behind warmth, breakfast, and silence.

And Kingsley.