Chapter 61
Katherine stormed out of the yoga field, her mat rolled too tightly, her fingers white from the grip. Her breath wasn’t even. Her mind definitely wasn’t.
Carolina caught up to her near the garden path.
“Katherine.”
Katherine didn’t slow down.
“Kat,” Carolina said again, more gently. “Stop. Breathe.”
They both paused under a shaded archway where ivy twisted up the wooden beams. Katherine turned, still holding the mat like a weapon against her chest.
“I don’t get him,” she burst out, voice sharp. “I really don’t. One minute he’s kissing me like I’m the only woman he’s ever wanted, the next he’s acting like I’m a stranger.”
Carolina tilted her head. “He looked pretty miserable out there.”
“That’s not the point.” Katherine’s voice cracked. “He could’ve said yes. That’s all he had to do. Just—say yes but no he had to ask if we were a couple. He looked at me like I was asking him to commit to a prison sentence.”
“You sure that’s what he meant?”
Katherine stared at her. “What else could it mean, Carolina?”
“I don’t know,” she said softly. “Shock? Fear? Men are idiots?”
Katherine huffed, pacing. “I thought we were moving forward. I thought the kisses meant something.”
“It did. Kat, I saw you after. You were glowing. And he—he’s different around you. It’s obvious. He’s just… Kingsley. He just fucks things up but I am sure that is not his intention.”
Katherine pressed her lips together, trying to will back the tears. “Then why come here at all? Why follow me, find me, show up with this whole… hero act, if he’s just going to fuck it up?”
Carolina stepped closer, placing a hand on her friend’s shoulder. “Maybe he didn’t expect the question. Maybe he just wants to be sure of what he heard”
“That’s not an excuse,” Katherine whispered. “I gave him the clearest opening I could. In front of everyone. I chose him. And he hesitated. Again.”
Carolina didn’t answer right away.
Then, gently, “Did you mean it when you asked him to be your partner?”
Katherine blinked at her. “Of course I did.”
“Then don’t let one stupid moment make you forget everything else he’s been trying to say. People mess up, Kat. Especially when they care too much. Maybe it’s not about the moment—it’s about what he does next.”
Katherine looked away, wiping at her eye quickly.
“I just wanted to feel chosen,” she said quietly. “Not like someone he’s still deciding about.”
Carolina gave her a soft smile. “You are chosen. Trust me. The man hasn’t stopped staring at you since he got here. He looked like he wanted to throw that poor girl off his mat and run across the field to you.”
Katherine laughed through her sniffle. “I noticed.”
“There you go.”
They stood together in the quiet a moment longer, the sounds of birds and distant wind chimes folding over them like a breeze.
Then Carolina nudged her with a grin. “So. You want revenge or redemption?”
Katherine raised an eyebrow. “What?”
“You heard me. We could go full savage—make him sweat a little. Or… maybe give him one more chance to prove he’s not a total idiot.”
Katherine smiled softly, more to herself than to Carolina. “Let’s see what he does first.”
Carolina looped her arm through hers. “Now that’s the spirit.”
And they walked off slowly, the day opening around them, the path ahead unwritten, uncertain—but not entirely closed.
Katherine stood at the edge of the lake, arms folded tightly across her chest, the breeze teasing strands of her hair across her face. The morning light broke gently over the water, casting long shadows, of gold across the blue. She didn’t turn when she heard him approach. She didn’t need to. She knew that rhythm of breath like her own heartbeat.
Kingsley stopped a few feet behind her. His voice came low, and soft, like he was afraid of breaking something already cracked.
“Katherine… I’m really sorry.”
She didn’t move. Not even a glance.
“I’m sorry I asked that kind of question in front of everyone like that,” he said. “I was just—God—I was just super excited that you asked me to go to the couple’s workshop with you. You have no idea what that meant to me. It threw me off. I… I messed up. I asked that dumbass question and I woke up instantly regretting it. That was not how it was supposed to come out. Not at all.”
Still nothing. Only the gentle sound of water lapping the shore.
“I really do want to go to the workshop with you,” he continued, taking a breath. “If you hadn’t asked me first, I would’ve asked you. I swear. I was just too slow. I’m just a fool for asking that kind of stupid question and making it sound like I didn’t care. I’m sorry for being foolish. Please, Katherine. This is all my disagreement. My mistake. Please… Let’s go together.”
She finally turned. Slowly. Her arms were still folded, her eyes still guarded.
“You want to go to the workshop with me?” she asked.
“Yes,” Kingsley said. “I do.”
Katherine looked at him long and hard, the silence stretching again. Then she shook her head lightly, a wounded sort of smile tugging at the edge of her mouth.
“Kingsley… I just don’t want to go through what I went through with you again,” she said, her voice trembling slightly. “I want to believe you’ve changed. I want to believe this is real. But just look at this morning. The way Devon asked Carolina? It was immediate. No hesitation. Because he had her in mind. He’s been carrying her in his heart since the beginning, and the moment that opportunity opened, he reached for her.”
She looked away, down at the water.
“But you?” she said, her voice barely above a whisper now. “You didn’t even say anything. And I thought—okay. Let me ask. I’ve seen your improvement. I’ve felt everything you’ve given to me these past few days. And I hoped—really hoped—it wasn’t a lie. So I asked. But when I asked, it was like you woke up. Like you didn’t even want it. Like I caught you off guard because you weren’t even thinking about me.”
She inhaled, trying to keep her emotions in check.
“And it just… it threw me back into that place. That place where I always wanted you to choose me and you never did. Where I thought maybe you only wanted me now because of the workshop. Or the retreat. Or the air out here that makes people reflect.”
She met his eyes again, and this time they were full of doubt, pain, and a cautious kind of hope.
“What if we leave this place and everything disappears?” she asked. “What if you go back to being the same person? What if you go back out there and I’m just… forgotten again?”
Kingsley stepped forward now, voice catching with rawness.
“Don’t say that,” he said. “Please don’t say that.”
His hand went to his chest. “Katherine, I came here because of you. Not for the program. Not for some self-help retreat. You. I came all the way to Brooklyn just to find you again. I crossed every line, and bent every rule—I even came in under a fake name because I had to see you. Because I couldn’t go another day not knowing if I still had a chance.”
He swallowed, breath shaking.
“I didn’t come here just to feel something temporary. I came because I need you. Because I’ve missed you every single day. Because I still love you.”
She blinked, quickly.
“I’m sorry I acted like a fool. I was a fool. But I promise you, Katherine, I won’t mess this up again. I won’t. I’ll say it right. I’ll fight for you. I’ll show up every damn day if you’ll let me. Just keep me close. Let me prove it. Please.”
He paused, hands clenched, trying to hold himself still while everything inside him trembled.
She looked at him a long while, expression unreadable. The wind lifted her hair again, and this time, she didn’t brush it away. She simply breathed in and exhaled. Slowly.
Then she nodded once.
“I’ve heard you,” she said softly. “And I’d like to go to the couple’s workshop with you.”
Kingsley blinked.
“You would?”
“Yes,” she said, arms unfolding. “But this is it. One shot. You fumble again, Kingsley… and I won’t be here waiting the next time.”
He nodded fiercely. “I won’t fumble. I swear.”
And for the first time since the morning, Katherine smiled. Just a little. But it was enough to make his knees go weak.
The leaves rustled above them, filtering dappled sunlight across the winding dirt path as they walked side by side. Not too close—Katherine kept a gentle space between them—but not far either. There was a softness in her shoulders now, not as guarded as before. Her arms hung loose at her sides, her pace unhurried. The silence was not heavy anymore. It was tentative. Curious. A hush where something new might take root.
Kingsley kept stealing glances at her like he was trying to memorize this version of her—the one that had not turned away. The one that had not said no.
He caught her looking once, just as he looked at her. She looked quickly away, the corner of her mouth twitching like she might’ve smiled, or almost smiled.
They kept walking.
A pair of bluebirds darted ahead of them across the path, skimming the air with light chirps, and Katherine slowed to watch them. Kingsley stopped too, pretending not to be watching her watch them.
“I forgot how pretty it is here,” she said finally, her voice quiet.
Kingsley smiled softly. “Yeah. I don’t think I noticed much of it… until you.”
She didn’t respond to that—just kept walking—but her silence didn’t feel like a wall. It felt like a door, still deciding if it wanted to be open.
After another few steps, he cleared his throat gently.
“You really meant it?” he asked. “About going to the couple’s workshop with me?”
She didn’t answer right away. Then:
“I meant it when I said one shot.”
He nodded slowly. “Then I won’t waste it.”
They passed by a row of sun-warmed stones leading down toward the wellness center. The sounds of other participants echoed faintly—laughs, doors creaking open, distant chatter—and it grounded them again in the world they’d left behind at the lake.
“Do you remember when we used to walk like this?” Katherine said suddenly. “You’d always reach for my hand when you thought I was mad at you.”
Kingsley looked at her, heart-tugging. “You were always mad at me.”
She smiled faintly. “Maybe.”
His voice turned quieter. “Can I…?” He glanced toward her hand.
Katherine didn’t answer. But she didn’t say no either. And after a beat, she let her fingers brush gently—barely—against his. Not quite holding. But not letting go.
They walked like that. Not saying much more. Just letting the silence stitch something small and fragile between them.
When the path opened up into the wider field near the hall where the couple’s workshop would be held, Katherine slowed again. She looked at the building, then at Kingsley.
“This isn’t forgiveness,” she said. “You know that.”
“I know,” he said. “This is a beginning.”
She gave him a look—measured, knowing. “A test.”
He nodded. “I’ll pass.”
“Mm,” she said, turning toward the building. “We’ll see.”
And yet—when she stepped forward this time, it was without hesitation. Kingsley followed. And the space between them had vanished.