Chapter 57

The air in the cabin was still, a kind of quiet that wasn’t peaceful—just thick. Carolina sat curled up on the edge of her bed, hugging a pillow tightly to her chest, her legs tucked underneath her like she was trying to disappear inside herself.

Katherine sat at the little desk by the window, half-pretending to write in her journal, but mostly just glancing up every few seconds to check on her friend.

Then—

A knock.

Carolina flinched.

Katherine turned, eyes narrowing as she stood. “I’ll get it.”

She crossed to the door and opened it halfway, blocking most of the doorway with her body.

It was Kingsley.

He stood there, hair tousled from the wind, his eyes unusually soft—tired in a way Katherine hadn’t seen since before the kiss.

Katherine’s shoulders tensed. “Um… what are you doing here?”

Kingsley looked past her, caught a glimpse of Carolina sitting on the bed behind her, and then dropped his gaze back to Katherine. “Sorry. Can I come in?”

Katherine didn’t move. “It’s actually… not a good time.”

He nodded slowly, taking the hint, but didn’t leave.

“I mean, Carolina isn’t feeling well,” she added. “She’s not in a good place right now. And I can’t just—have you come in here like we’re about to talk and joke and whatever, while she’s sitting right there feeling like her heart’s in pieces. That’s not right.”

Kingsley took a breath. “I understand.”

“She can’t feel like she’s breaking, and we’re in her face just… gisting,” she continued, voice lower now, gentler. “Your friend… I don’t know if he’s told you, but he really hurt her. She trusted him. And right now, she needs space. Not reminders.”

Kingsley nodded again. “I’m not here for you,” he said quietly. “I’m here… because of Carolina.”

Katherine narrowed her eyes slightly, hand still on the doorframe. “Because of Carolina?” she echoed, brows lifting. “Why?”

Kingsley shifted where he stood, his voice was soft but steady. “She’s been refusing to see Devon. He—he doesn’t want to push her. But he’s worried. And he asked me to come… to talk to her. To explain.”

Katherine’s shoulders didn’t relax yet. Her guard was still up, but her voice softened just a fraction. “Explain what?”

“They talked earlier,” Kingsley said, glancing at Carolina briefly, then back at Katherine. “When they met by the lake… he told her everything. About the past. About the girl. The baby. But she got angry, and she left before he could explain the whole thing. Before he could tell her how much he regrets it… and what he’s trying to do to make it right.”

Katherine’s eyes flicked toward Carolina, who hadn’t moved from her bed. She still sat curled into herself, her cheek pressed to the pillow, the fabric faintly damp from where her tears had soaked through earlier.

“Carolina,” Katherine said gently, turning halfway. “Do you want to hear him out? Not Devon. Just Kingsley. Just to listen?”

For a moment, Carolina didn’t move. Then she slowly sat up straighter and nodded once, still not speaking.

Katherine turned back to the door and opened it wider.

“You can come in,” she said.

Kingsley nodded his thanks, his movements careful and slow as he stepped inside the cabin like it was a sacred space. He didn’t try to sit. He didn’t try to talk immediately. He just stood, his hands at his sides, eyes scanning the quiet in the room before settling on Carolina.

“Thank you,” he said softly. “For letting me in.”

Carolina didn’t respond.

Katherine moved to sit on the edge of Carolina’s bed beside her, offering quiet support. Her presence was solid, anchoring, like a wall that Carolina could lean against without having to say anything.

Kingsley stood a few feet away, his posture gentle, almost apologetic.

“I’m not here to defend him,” Kingsley said finally. “I’m just here to help explain. Because he knows… he messed up. And he knows there’s no undoing that.”

He paused. The silence stretched a little. Then he continued.

“When it happened, Devon was twenty. He’d just been offered a full scholarship to study abroad. It was the kind of opportunity his family could never have afforded. He panicked. He thought if he stayed and claimed the pregnancy, he’d lose it all. So he told himself the worst kind of lie—that it wasn’t his baby. And he left.”

Carolina’s eyes brimmed with tears again, but she didn’t look away. She was listening.

Kingsley continued, his voice steady. “Years later, after he finished school and started working, he couldn’t stop thinking about what he’d done. So he went back. Looked for her. And he found her. The girl had kept the baby. She raised her alone.”

He swallowed hard. “The child was already eight when he found them. A little girl.”

Carolina looked down.

“He tried everything,” Kingsley went on. He begged her, Carolina. He begged her to let him be part of the child’s life. He did everything he could think of—letters, calls, showing up just to sit outside her house and wait for her to speak to him. But she didn’t. She wouldn’t. And her mother…” Kingsley gave a small, dry laugh, without any real amusement. “Her mother told him to let them be. To stop disrupting their peace. That if he really cared, he’d leave them alone. And he… he did.”

He looked at Carolina then. Not pleading, just searching—hoping she’d hear him.

“He knew he had to. He had no right to force it. None. He knew that. God knows he did. So he stopped. He stayed away. But he still hoped… that maybe one day, when the little girl was older, she might want to know who he was. He kept hoping.”

Carolina’s breathing was quiet, measured, as she watched him from the bed. Katherine’s hand hadn’t left her back.

Kingsley continued. “Now, about the court stuff—the custody case? That… that wasn’t him.”

Carolina blinked.

“It was his parents. When they found out she wouldn’t let him see the child, they decided they wanted their grandchild no matter what. And without even telling him, they started the process. Filed paperwork. Used his name.”

Carolina’s eyes widened slightly. “What?”

“He didn’t know,” Kingsley said. “Not at first. He only found out later—way later—when she called and cursed him out, rightfully. Said she thought he’d changed, but he was still trying to take the child like a possession. He was shocked. Furious. He went straight to his parents. Screamed at them. Told them to withdraw everything. And when they refused…” Kingsley paused, voice tightening. “That’s when he left. That’s when he came here. He was falling apart. Everything was too much. And he didn’t want to become the kind of man he once was—cold, selfish, proud.”

Silence settled in the room like mist.

“He’s grown now,” Kingsley said, slower. “He’s not twenty anymore. He’s not hiding behind excuses. He’s sorry. And I know that doesn’t erase what happened. Nothing can. But he regrets it every single day. He knows what he lost, and what he’ll probably never get back.”

Carolina swallowed hard, her fingers knotting into the hem of her shirt.

Kingsley added, his voice barely above a whisper, “He just… he just wants you to understand who he is now. That he’s not proud of who he was. But he’s trying to be better.”

For a long moment, the only sound in the cabin was the faint rustle of leaves outside the window, and the small creak of the bed frame as Carolina shifted slightly.

She finally looked up, her voice quiet but steady, full of conflict and the beginnings of clarity.

“I didn’t even hear him out,” she said, almost to herself. “He was trying to explain, but when he mentioned something about fighting for custody in court, I just—I got so angry. It brought up all my old stuff. I think… I think he was about to talk about the involvement of his parents when I walked off.”

She rubbed her eyes with the heel of her hand. “I feel so bad right now.”

Katherine gave her a soft look and kept her hand on her back.

“I understand,” Carolina said again, more to Kingsley this time. “I don’t know. Just… tell him we can talk. Okay? We can talk.”

Kingsley’s shoulders dropped in quiet relief. “Actually,” he said, “you guys can talk during the private massage.”

Carolina blinked. “What are you talking about? The private massage is for you and Devon. You both won it.”

Kingsley gave a faint grin. “Come on, you know who I am, right? I’ve had more massages than I can count. I don’t even need it.”

He looked from her to Katherine, then back. “What you need right now is space. And time. Just a quiet place to sit with everything and talk it through. This’ll give you that. It’s okay.”

Carolina stared at him a moment longer. Her lips parted like she wanted to say something but didn’t have the right words. Then she gave a small nod, eyes warm and a little glossy.

“Thank you so much, Kingsley. You’re… you’re really a nice person.”

She let out a weak, almost embarrassed laugh. “And I’m sorry about everything I said about you. Earlier. I didn’t know.”

Kingsley gave her a soft smile, humble, unbothered. “It’s okay. You were just protecting your friend.”

There was a moment—quiet and gentle—where all three of them just sat with it. The tension in the room had shifted, softened, not completely resolved but no longer bristling and raw.