Chapter 45

The breakfast hall buzzed with soft chatter, spoons clinking against ceramic bowls, the occasional yawn slipping through conversation. Morning light filtered through the open windows, golden and gentle, cutting across long wooden tables where campers gathered in mismatched sweatshirts and socks.

Katherine sat beside Carolina, nursing a cup of green tea she hadn’t quite decided to drink. Across the hall, Kingsley sat two tables away, not looking at her—but she could feel his presence like a warm pull in her chest.

Just then, one of the facilitators stepped up onto the little wooden platform near the front. She clapped once, sharp and light.

“Good morning, everyone,” she said with a smile. “Quick announcement before the next activity.”

The room quieted.

“If you have a message you’d like to send to your family or friends,” she continued, “tomorrow is our official Calling Day. You’re welcome to come by the call center any time after breakfast. You can make a voice message or leave a note to be sent.”

A few campers murmured quietly, intrigued.

“Also,” she added, “if you’re expecting anything—or even if you’re not—you can check in with us. Sometimes your loved ones leave a voicemail or a letter we’ve been holding for this moment. If someone left you a message, we’ll play it for you tomorrow.”

Her smile softened. “That’s all. Enjoy the rest of your breakfast.”

The hall rustled back to life.

The afternoon sun slanted through the tall pine trees, scattering golden light across the forest floor. Campers gathered at the edge of the clearing, a mix of curiosity and competitiveness in the air. Facilitators were setting up ropes between trees, balancing beams, blindfolds, and notepads.

One of the facilitators, a tall man with a clipboard and a lanyard, stepped forward.

“Alright everyone, today we’re doing something special. We call it the Trust Trail Challenge. It’s a mix of coordination, teamwork, and communication. You’ll work in pairs—one of you will be blindfolded, the other will guide them through the course without touching them. Only verbal instructions allowed.”

A few campers laughed nervously. Some groaned.

“But that’s not all,” the facilitator grinned. “At the halfway point, we’ll switch roles. The speaker becomes the blindfolded one. First pair to complete the course wins the Final Trust Challenge Prize—a sunset canoe ride with a gourmet snack basket for two. And eternal bragging rights.”

A ripple of excitement passed through the crowd.

Names were drawn randomly, but when Kingsley’s name came up and Katherine’s followed right after, everyone around them looked over with curiosity. Even Carolina gave Katherine a wide-eyed smirk. Katherine glanced at Kingsley. He raised an eyebrow as if to say, You in?

She gave a half-shrug. “Let’s do it.”

Katherine was blindfolded first. Standing at the starting line, her hands at her sides, she tried not to fidget. Behind her, Kingsley stood with a careful distance. His voice came through, calm and precise.

“Okay… three steps forward. There’s a root coming up—lift your foot high. Right foot first.”

She followed the sound of his voice, heart thudding—not from fear, but the strange intimacy of it. He wasn’t close, and yet it felt like he was right there inside her skin. He knew her voice too well. He knew how to talk her through fear. He always had.

“Left,” he said. “Good. Okay, now stop. There’s a narrow log—take a deep breath. One foot at a time.”

Her balance wobbled, but his soft, “You’ve got it,” kept her steady.

They switched roles at the midpoint.

When it was her turn to guide him, Katherine found herself slipping back into a rhythm that felt familiar—us, the version of them that once worked. Her voice was firm but gentle, her instructions clear.

“No, your other left,” she teased once. He laughed under his breath, and even she smiled a little.

When they crossed the finish line, the facilitator shouted, “We’ve got a winner! Katherine and Kingsley!”

Applause followed. Katherine pulled off her blindfold and looked at Kingsley. Their eyes met—not romantic, not flirtatious—just a long, knowing look that said, We still work.

The prize was announced again: a sunset canoe ride and a picnic basket for two.

Katherine raised her eyebrows. “So… what are we going to do with that?”

Kingsley gave a crooked grin. “Guess we’ll find out.”

The golden light of the afternoon stretched across the surface of the lake like a living sheet of glass. The trees bordering the water swayed gently, their reflections dancing on the ripples stirred by Katherine’s paddle as she helped guide the small canoe forward. There was a picnic basket between them, neatly arranged with treats, fruit, cake, and two tumblers of chilled hibiscus tea.

Katherine’s eyes sparkled with amusement and surprise as she looked around.

“Wow,” she murmured, almost to herself. “So we finally got to do this.”

Kingsley looked up from his end of the boat. “What’s that?”

“This,” she gestured vaguely to the lake, the trees, the perfectly prepared basket. “It looks so nice. Like, oh my God. The food. The little cake. The whole thing. The basket even has those tiny embroidered napkins… It’s so Carolina. No wonder Carolina enjoyed this so much.”

She laughed softly. “Now I get why she and Devon kissed. The mood here? Kind of hard to resist.”

Kingsley blinked. “Wait, who kissed?”

Katherine laughed, the sound soft and bright in the quiet space around them. “Your roommate—Devon. He kissed my best friend, Carolina. They’re having a little something, apparently.”

Kingsley raised his eyebrows, amused. “Huh. I didn’t know about that.”

“Well,” she teased, “don’t you guys talk?”

“Sometimes. When it’s necessary,” Kingsley said with a shrug, smiling.

“Well,” she grinned, reaching into the basket for a grape, “maybe he’s not a kiss-and-tell man. I respect that. But you know us girls, we’re going to talk. That’s what we do.”

They sat there for a moment in companionable silence, the canoe gently rocking beneath them, the faint hum of wind curling around their shoulders.

Kingsley watched her, the sunlight catching on her skin like she belonged in that golden hour. He shook his head with a faint smile. “I’m just… happy being here with you. I’d give everything for this moment.”

Katherine looked at him, startled by the quiet sincerity in his voice. She didn’t look away, but there was a flicker of something she tucked behind her eyes.

“So,” she said carefully, “tell me, Kingsley. Why do you want me back?”

He blinked, caught.

“What about Beth?” she continued. “I thought I was only a substitute… because of my eyes. You said I looked like her. That’s why you married me. And then you left me for her—so, why are you here now?”

Kingsley swallowed. “Because our marriage is barely holding on. It’s not even a marriage anymore. It’s a business agreement in expensive clothes. I… I’m divorcing her, Katherine. I came here to tell you that. To find you. To see if I still had a chance.”

She watched him carefully. “You divorced me, Kingsley. And now you’re here asking what if I came back. What if you miss Beth again and change your mind?”

He shook his head, voice low and firm. “I won’t. Because the woman I thought Beth was—the one I fell for in college—wasn’t real. She showed me a version of herself that wasn’t sustainable. When she came back, I was chasing that illusion. But when I married her… she unraveled. Cold. Controlling. Everything I didn’t see coming.”

Katherine stayed quiet.

“But you?” he said softly. “You were always real. I met you as yourself, married you and you were still yourself, I left you, and you were still yourself. I see you now—your strength, your kindness, your fire—and I know you haven’t changed into someone else. You’ve grown. But you’re still you. That’s the woman I love.”

She looked away quickly, as if needing the horizon to anchor her.

“You know your parents will never accept this, right?” she said. “They were thrilled when you married Beth. I heard about it from Anna herself—she said, ‘Finally, a woman who fits our world.’ They won’t ever be okay with you choosing me again.”

Kingsley’s voice didn’t waver. “I don’t care about my parents. They didn’t teach me how to love. They taught me how to perform. I don’t mind leaving them behind, their approval, their money, the whole show… if you’d just say yes.”

He leaned closer, the boat creaking slightly beneath them.

“You’re worth more than all of it. Every single bit.”

Katherine stared at him for a long second, her chest rising and falling slowly. Her lips parted, but no words came. She looked down at her hands, her fingers clutching the edge of the seat.

Finally, she whispered, “It’s getting late. Let’s head back.”

Kingsley didn’t argue. They started paddling back, the rhythm quiet, the moment suspended.

About halfway across the water, Katherine broke the silence again.

“So… who are you expecting to call you tomorrow?” she asked casually. “Your wife?”

Kingsley gave a low chuckle. “No. I’m not expecting anyone to call me. I might call my secretary though—just to check on the company, ask some questions, see how things are running.”

She nodded slowly. “Right. Business first.”

He looked over at her. “And what about you? Who’ll be calling you?”

Katherine tilted her head, thoughtful. “I don’t know… I didn’t really tell anyone I was coming here. Except Jordan. He might check in. Or not. I guess I could call to say hi.”

Kingsley’s eyebrows lifted. “Jordan?”

She caught the look on his face and rolled her eyes. “Oh, stop. No, we’re not a thing. We’re just friends. Good friends.”

He gave her a look. “Can a guy and a girl really be just friends?”

She laughed, shaking her head. “You sound so jealous. It’s kind of adorable. But, seriously—you look so uncool right now.”

He grinned, shaking his head. “I’m not jealous.”

“You are.”

“Maybe a little.”

Their laughter floated across the water, easy, unforced, warm.

But as they reached the shore and stepped out, the lightness faded. Katherine walked ahead of him quietly, her back straight, her thoughts hidden again.

Kingsley followed behind her, every step heavy with the truth: he had said everything. But whether it would be enough… was still a question hanging in the space between them.