Chapter 42
The sun had begun to settle into a warm amber glow as Carolina returned from her picnic, her face flushed—not just from the sun, but from something else entirely. She pushed open the cabin door, and Katherine sat up immediately from her bed where she’d been flipping through a wellness brochure without really reading it.
Katherine grinned wide. “Girl, tell me everything. Don’t even act like nothing happened. What went down at Willow Lake?”
Carolina paused at the door, biting her lip, cheeks blooming a deep pink.
“Oh. My. God.” Katherine sat all the way up. “Why are you blushing like that? Talk!”
Carolina laughed, shy and giddy, and walked to the bed opposite Katherine’s, sitting down with her legs crossed under her. “We… kissed.”
Katherine’s eyes widened. “What do you mean you kissed?!”
Carolina threw her head back with a groan and then nodded, laughing. “We kissed. I know—it’s wild. But it just… happened.”
“Girl!” Katherine slapped a pillow. “Start from the beginning. Don’t skip. Don’t summarize. I need details.”
Carolina smiled, tucking a strand of hair behind her ear. “Okay, so, during the scavenger hunt, we were paired together. Devon was super laid-back, not pushy at all. We ended up talking a lot—like, everything just flowed. And we realized we had so many things in common. Same weird taste in music. Same petty obsessions with organizing our playlists.”
Katherine raised a brow. “That’s actually huge.”
Carolina nodded enthusiastically. “Right? Then after the hunt, we got that picnic thing as our prize. We went to Willow Lake and just… talked for hours. It felt like something out of a cheesy indie movie. Then at one point, he looked at me and just asked if he could kiss me.”
“And you said?”
“I said yes.” Carolina grinned.
Katherine shrieked and tossed a pillow at her. “Girl! I did not see this coming! You out here living in a rom-com and didn’t even send me a warning?”
Carolina laughed, grabbing the pillow. “I know. It’s insane. I feel like I barely know him but also… I don’t know. I feel seen, you know?”
“Well, go girl,” Katherine said, standing up and doing a little mock dance. “I’m so happy for you! At least one of us is getting it right.”
They both chuckled.
Then Carolina’s expression turned slightly nervous. “But, like… is it moving too fast? Do you think it’s weird? I mean, it’s just a kiss but—”
Katherine waved a hand. “Girl. You kissed. You didn’t marry him. You didn’t sleep with him. Just breathe. Enjoy the moment.”
Carolina nodded slowly, still smiling. “Yeah. You’re right. I guess I’m just scared to like someone again. But… I really like him.”
Katherine softened. “That’s sweet. Maybe you found your prince charming.”
Carolina grinned. “Maybe.”
Then she added, “And what’s funny is—Devon is Kingsley’s roommate.”
Katherine blinked. “Wait… what?”
Carolina laughed at her stunned face. “Yup. Devon. Kingsley’s roommate.”
Katherine stared, then groaned. “Oh my God. That is so crazy. I can’t even escape him properly.”
Carolina smirked. “Looks like the universe is messy on purpose.”
They both fell into laughter, the kind that made their eyes tear up, and for the first time in a long time, Katherine felt something close to lighthearted again.
The camp’s evening air was cool and humming with life. Crickets had started their slow symphony, and the lamps scattered across the lawn gave off a warm, amber glow as the campers made their way to the open clearing near the fire pit.
Blankets had been laid out in circles, with cushions and lanterns in the middle of each cluster. A sign near the path read:
Evening Bonding: Campfire Conversations & Connection Rounds
Please find a seat. Prompts will be shared. Speak honestly.
Katherine and Carolina arrived together, both wrapped in light shawls. Carolina’s face still wore a secret smile from earlier, and Katherine nudged her gently with her elbow.
“You’re still glowing.”
Carolina whispered back, “I’m trying not to.”
They joined one of the circles, sitting close together at first, but as more campers arrived, people were encouraged to mix up and sit beside someone new.
To Katherine’s quiet dismay, Kingsley walked over and settled beside her, a respectful distance apart. She didn’t say anything. Neither did he. They just sat in the soft flicker of lantern light as one of the facilitators stepped into the center with a wooden box.
“Good evening, everyone,” the facilitator smiled warmly. “Tonight is about safe vulnerability. Inside this box are folded cards with simple prompts. Each person will take one, read it aloud, and respond. You may pass if you’re not comfortable. This isn’t about pressure—it’s about presence. Let’s begin.”
The box was passed around the circle.
Devon, seated across from Carolina, was the first brave soul. He picked a card, opened it, and read aloud:
“Describe a time you felt truly seen.”
He paused, glanced at Carolina, then smiled as he shared a gentle story about a childhood friend who once stood up for him when he couldn’t speak for himself.
Next went around, person to person—some funny, some emotional, some awkward. There was laughter. A few tears. Glances exchanged between strangers and almost-lovers.
Then the box landed in front of Katherine.
She drew a card and slowly read:
“What’s something you’re afraid to admit?”
The group quieted, instinctively sensing this might be a real one.
Katherine took a breath.
“I’m afraid to admit… that I still carry grief from the version of myself I had to let go of. There’s this woman I used to be—who believed in forever, who thought love was enough to fix anything. Losing her… was like losing someone I loved.”
A pause. Some nods. Kingsley looked down, his jaw tense.
Katherine gently folded the card and placed it beside her.
Carolina gave her hand a small squeeze.
Then it was Kingsley’s turn.
He reached in, drew a card, and read:
“What’s something you wish you could say to someone, but haven’t?”
A longer pause. The fire crackled.
Kingsley’s voice was lower than usual, rough.
“I wish I could tell someone… that I see now. I see what I didn’t then. And that I’m sorry for not fighting for what mattered most.”
The silence that followed was loud.
Katherine didn’t look at him. But her fingers curled tighter into the blanket around her legs.
The evening rolled on with more stories, more honesty, the kind only the quiet of the night could allow.
Later, as the facilitators dismissed the group and people stood up in pairs, some walking hand in hand, others slipping off to stargaze or sit quietly alone, Katherine and Carolina were still seated, wrapped in silence, gazing into the dying embers.
Carolina shifted beside her and suddenly nudged Katherine gently. “Devon’s calling me.”
Katherine glanced up and saw Devon standing a short distance away, a teasing smile on his face and two fingers raised in that unmistakable come here motion.
“Oh my God,” Katherine said, grinning, “you two are so gross. Go get your man,” Katherine affirmed, swatting her lightly. “Shoo. I’ll be here.”
Carolina stood and brushed off her pants. “I’ll be back, alright?”
“You better,” Katherine replied, half-smiling.
She watched as Devon reached out, gently took Carolina’s hand, and the two of them began walking into the dim trail, heads tilted toward each other, talking low and easy. Katherine smiled to herself, genuinely happy.
Then she heard the voice behind her.
“Please. Can I talk to you?”
She turned. Kingsley
She studied his face a moment, then gave a small nod. “Yeah. You can.”
He stepped closer, slow, careful. He didn’t sit, just stood near her, hands in his jacket pockets.
“About what you said earlier,” he began, voice quieter now. “It really… broke me down.”
Katherine looked at him.
“I’m really sorry,” he said, more firmly. “I was selfish. I kept thinking about what I missed, about memories, and not about what I did to you. I tried to be cute and nostalgic, when I should’ve just respected your space. I didn’t even think about how hard all of it was for you.”
He paused, the night holding his words like breath in cold air.
“I just wanted to share a moment, but I see how wrong my timing was. I’m sorry. I hope—our friendship is still okay?”
Katherine looked down for a second, her fingers playing with the edge of her shawl.
“It’s okay,” she said. “Our friendship is still intact.”
She turned to him now, meeting his eyes, and he continued “I heard what you said too, Katherine. When they asked you what you were afraid to admit. You said you still carry grief for the woman you used to be—the one who believed in forever, who thought love could fix everything.”
He swallowed. “That got to me. Because… I know I had a hand in destroying that woman. I know I helped in breaking her down. And I’m sorry.”
Katherine looked like she was about to speak, but he kept going.
“I hope I can help you get her back. Not as anything more. But as a friend. I just want to be there for you… to help you feel like yourself again. Whoever the lucky man ends up being in your life, I hope you’re better for him. And I hope he sees what I didn’t see in time.”
Katherine blinked at him, stunned silent.
A moment passed.
She exhaled shakily. “God, thank you. That—means more than you know.”
Kingsley nodded, looking back toward the fire.
Katherine turned his attention back to her “And I heard what you said too. When they asked what you wish you could say to someone.”
She turned to him again. “Can I ask… who was that person?”
Kingsley gave her a knowing look, soft, vulnerable. “You know who.”
Katherine stared at him, her chest tightening.
“I was talking to you,” he said.
She gave a small smile, almost pained. “You said you were sorry for not fighting for what mattered most.”
“I meant it.”
“I know,” she said. “And I accept your apology, Kingsley. It’s okay.”
And it was. Not perfect. Not pain-free. But okay.
They sat in that silence a while longer, neither needing to say more.
Above them, the stars blinked gently over the camp. The fire sighed low, and something unspoken settled between them—no longer heavy, no longer sharp. Just… human.