Chapter 34

8:07 PM — The Quiet Brew Café

Brooklyn, New York

The last customer had left. The chairs were stacked. The windows were dimmed. Katherine had just finished wiping down the espresso machine when she heard the soft knock.

She didn’t go immediately.

She let him wait for a moment.

Then she walked over and unlocked the door, pushing it open. The cold from the outside rushed in with him, but her eyes were colder.

Kingsley stepped inside, slowly, as if unsure if he’d be allowed to.

Before he could say hi or even draw a breath—

“I am not a substitute.”

Her voice hit like glass. No softness. No curve. Just sharp edges.

“I am beyond a substitute, Kingsley,” she continued, folding her arms. “You don’t just get to come to me every time your life goes off the rails. I’m not your emergency exit. I’m not your second choice.”

“Katherine—” he tried, voice low.

“No,” she cut him off, “you did this before. You remember? When you I took you to the hospital ? I was the one who took care of you. Stayed in the hospital with you. You know what you did after that? You left. You walked right back into your career, into your ego, and left me standing there like I never mattered.”

Kingsley looked down.

“And when it became convenient, when things settled, you came back. And I—” she swallowed— “I let you. Because I loved you.”

She took one step toward him.

“Then Beth came back. She waved her perfect little image in your face and suddenly you went to her, you didn’t remember you had a wife. So you left again. Just like that. Like I was a moment. A mood. A mistake.”

Kingsley opened his mouth, but again, she didn’t give him the chance.

“And now you’re here. Again. Because what—Beth’s no longer perfect? You miss someone to make your coffee? You think this is love?”

“I don’t think,” Kingsley said, voice shaking. “I know.”

“You know?” she laughed bitterly. “You know what I think? I think you’re just scared. Scared of losing control. Scared of being alone. Scared of not having someone orbiting around your chaos.”

“I ran to your friend,” he admitted, “because I was desperate. I thought maybe she could help me reach you. I know that was wrong. But I didn’t know what else to do.”

Katherine’s eyes flashed.

“You humiliated me. you told me you only loved me because of my eyes, I had the same eyes as your ex girlfriend and now she is back you don’t want me anymore. You called me a gold digger when I tried to talk during the divorce. You didn’t listen. You didn’t even flinch. I begged you to see reason and you—”

“I was a fool,” Kingsley said, stepping forward. “A big one. The biggest. I see that now. I see the pain in your voice and the way you look at me. And I hate myself for it. But Katherine, you have to understand… I didn’t love you for your eyes. I didn’t even realize how stupid that sounded until it came out of my mouth. I loved everything about you. Your heart. Your strength. Your fire. You’re a goddess, Katherine. And I let you go.”

He was trembling. “If it means letting Beth go, I will. It’s you I want. It’s always been you. Please believe me.”

Katherine stared at him, stunned for a moment.

And then her face twisted—not in pity, not in sadness.

In fury.

“So that’s it? You’ll just toss Beth aside the way you tossed me? Do you think love is just some revolving door you walk in and out of when it suits you? That you can plug people into your life and then yank them out when it gets inconvenient?”

She stepped closer, face inches from his.

“You don’t get to love me now. Not after what you did. I don’t love you anymore. I don’t want anything to do with you. And I don’t appreciate you being here.”

Kingsley looked stunned. Broken.

“I’m love you, I am crazy about you and I miss you so much, if only you know what your presence is doing to me ” he whispered.

“You’re a married man, Kingsley,” she shot back. “Go think about your wife. Stop chasing people who no longer want you.”

A long silence hung between them.

Then, calm and final, she said, “If I see you here again, I will report you. You think I care about your reputation? I don’t. Not anymore. So leave. We are done. Whatever existed between us—dead. Finished. Gone.”

She walked over to the door and opened it, holding it wide.

“Please use the door,” she said, her voice cool as steel.

Kingsley didn’t move.

“I’m sorry,” he said. “I love you. So much.”

“Leave,” she said again, this time quieter. “Before I stop being nice.”

Kingsley stepped out slowly. As he crossed the threshold, she added one last thing:

“I hope you remember what you said earlier… that if I gave you this conversation, you’d leave me alone. You gave me your word. Keep it. Let me heal.”

Kingsley nodded once, eyes glistening, then turned and walked down the quiet sidewalk.

The door clicked shut behind him.

The Next day, Beth had arrived in Brooklyn, she went straight to Spring-view hotel to confront Kingsley, she stepped into the hotel lobby, her heels clicking sharply against the polished floor. The concierge looked up from the desk, giving her a polite smile.

“I’m here to see Mr. Kingsley Rowe,” she said curtly, clutching her purse tightly. “Room 305.”

The man tapped the computer. “Mr. Rowe checked out this morning, ma’am.”

Beth blinked. “What?”

“Yes. Around 8:45.”

She pulled out her phone immediately, dialing him. No answer.

She called again. Still nothing.

Kingsley, meanwhile, was in the back seat of his car, halfway across the bridge, exhausted and hollow-eyed, heading home. He hadn’t told anyone—not even the driver—about Katherine. He hadn’t expected Beth to find out anything. He thought he still had time to figure it all out.

But Beth wasn’t going to wait.

She turned sharply from the desk, slipped her sunglasses on, and headed back outside. She wasn’t leaving Brooklyn yet. Not without seeing this “Katherine ” girl for herself.

The café was busy as always. The morning rush hadn’t quite ended. Katherine was behind the counter, tying her apron again, restocking the shelves, humming softly to herself. She hadn’t seen Kingsley since last night, but the conversation still burned in her chest. Her hands still trembled slightly whenever she thought about it.

And then the door opened.

A woman in a long beige trench coat and heels stepped inside like she owned the air around her. She took her sunglasses off slowly.

Katherine didn’t know who she was at first. But the expression—that entitled, ice-cold glare—gave her a clue.

Beth Rowe.

Beth walked directly toward the counter.

“Can I help you?” Katherine asked.

Beth leaned in, not bothering to lower her voice. “Yes. You can leave my husband alone.”

The entire café seemed to pause—mugs stopped mid-air, a hush crawling over the hum of espresso machines and chatter. A couple of people turned.

Katherine's eyes narrowed. “Excuse me?”

“You heard me right,” Beth said, her voice low but sharp. “He’s a married man. Have some respect for yourself.”

From the back corner, Jordan stood up slowly, watching the exchange unfold, his jaw tight.

Beth gave Katherine one last look, something close to a sneer. “I’m just here to warn you. Stay away from him. You’re not the first, but you can be the last.”

Katherine didn’t speak. Her mouth twitched, but she said nothing. Her hands clenched behind the counter.

The silence in the café grew heavier, more curious. A woman near the register subtly pulled out her phone.

Beth caught the movement. She straightened and smoothed her coat.

No drama. No scenes.

Not here.

She turned and walked right back out the door, her heels pounding the floor with precision.

Katherine stayed still for a moment, her eyes locked on the door even after it shut behind Beth.

Then she exhaled, slowly, her body stiff with anger.

When she finally looked to the side, Jordan was staring at her—arms folded, concern all over his face.

“You okay?” he asked.

Katherine nodded once embarrassed, but her jaw was clenched tight.

“Yes,” she whispered. “I’m ok.”

Jordan took a step forward.

But Katherine just turned her back and walked to the sink, needing to do something—anything—with her hands. Her heart was pounding, her ears ringing, and her face was burning with the humiliation of it all.

Because even though she’d told Kingsley it was over…

Now it felt like she was truly being dragged into the middle of a war she didn’t ask for.