Chapter 31

Kingsley stayed there longer than he should have.

His coffee had long gone cold, untouched for the most part, just resting in his hands as he sat back in the corner of The Quiet Brew. He wasn’t trying to be invisible, but he wasn’t trying to make a scene either. He just needed to be near her. Even if she didn’t want to see him. Even if she had every reason to hate him.

From where he sat, he had a quiet, steady view of her. Katherine. Moving like she always did, purposeful, elegant in that no-nonsense way. She kept her eyes on her work, didn’t glance at him once, and Kingsley respected that—though it pained him.

The café began to thin. The lunch rush had died down, and the crowd that once hummed with conversation and orders was settling into scattered pockets of quiet. A few people still lingered with laptops and mugs, but the counter had no line now.

And she finally looked up.

Katherine stared across the café at him for a long moment, then set the rag in her hand aside, pulled off her apron, and walked over.

“What did I say to you earlier?” she said flatly, standing beside his table, her arms folded. “I thought I told you to take the coffee and leave.”

Kingsley straightened in his chair, trying not to let the sting of her tone show. “I know,” he said quietly. “But I just… I needed to try. Katherine, I just needed to talk to you.”

Her eyes narrowed slightly. “You’re not trying, Kingsley. You’re haunting me. You sit here like this is normal. It’s not. You don’t get to walk back into my life like this. So please—if you’re done nursing that coffee, leave. You’ve done enough.”

“I’m not trying to cause a scene,” he said, standing now, softly pleading. “I’m not trying to make things worse for you. I just—please, can we talk? Just somewhere quiet? You can say whatever you want after. Yell, curse me out—I deserve it. But I need to say something to you.”

She started to shake her head again, sharper this time. “I’m done talking. I said no. If you don’t want your coffee, leave. So other people can come in here and feel peace again.”

Before Kingsley could say anything else, a voice cut through the soft hum of the café.

“Is this man bothering you?”

It was direct. Male. Slightly raised.

Both of them turned.

A tall, sharp-featured man with neatly combed hair and rolled-up sleeves stood near the pastry case, holding a book in one hand and a ceramic mug in the other. He looked straight at Katherine with concern in his eyes.

Katherine blinked in recognition. “Jordan,” she said, voice surprised but calm. “It’s okay. He’s not… he’s not bothering me. I was just talking to him.”

Jordan’s brow furrowed a little, but he didn’t move. “You sure?”

She nodded. “Yeah. It’s fine.”

Kingsley, turning toward the stranger, frowned slightly. “Excuse me,” he said, voice measured but clearly annoyed. “Who are you and why are you interfering?”

Jordan raised an eyebrow. “I could ask you the same thing, man. But I guess we both already know the answer.”

Katherine stepped between them quickly, her voice more firm now. “Okay, that’s enough. Both of you.”

Jordan looked at her for a long beat, then finally gave a tight nod and stepped back.

Kingsley, still standing, ran a hand down his face and turned to Katherine again, the weariness back in his tone. “I didn’t come here for drama. I came here for you. Just you.”

She gave him one last look, unreadable, then reached down, picked up the now-cold cup he’d barely touched, and dumped it in the trash.

“Next time,” she said quietly, “don’t bother.”

And just like that, she turned and walked back behind the counter.

Kingsley stood there, motionless, his hands now empty. The entire café seemed heavier, like it had been holding its breath and was finally letting it out.

He turned slowly, left the café, and stepped back into the fading afternoon light.

Katherine stood for a moment behind the counter, watching Kingsley as he turned and walked out, shoulders tight with something—regret maybe, or bitterness, or that deep, grinding ache that came from watching something slip through your fingers. But she didn’t let it sit too long. She blinked once, then twice, then inhaled sharply through her nose, pushing all of that down where it belonged—somewhere sealed off and quiet. She turned back to the bar, her hands already moving in muscle memory, reaching for a new set of cups.

The café was still softly buzzing, sunlight pooling through the wide front windows, catching in the steam of milk and espresso and warm air. She pulled a fresh cup, poured the coffee, added the perfect cream swirl. And then she slid the drink onto a tray and stepped out from behind the counter, her apron brushing her jeans as she crossed the floor.

Jordan looked up just as she approached, his eyebrows lifting slightly in surprise. He was seated at the corner table, the same one he always picked—the one near the window but tucked just enough to feel private. Katherine set the coffee down gently in front of him.

“This one’s on the house,” she said softly, trying to smile but not quite pulling it off. Her fingers tapped nervously against the tray. “And also, I just… I wanted to say sorry. For the other night. The way I left that restaurant, it wasn’t fair to you. It was… it was weird. I know. I’m sorry.”

Jordan gave a small nod, his expression softening. He leaned back in his chair, eyes steady on hers. “You don’t have to apologize so much. I mean, it wasn’t the best ending, but I get it. You had stuff going on. Still…”—his smile tilted sideways—“If you’re really sorry, how about you make it up to me? Grab some ice cream later. Or anything else you feel like. We never got to finish our conversation.”

Katherine laughed lightly—real this time, if just a little fragile. “Okay,” she said, brushing a loose strand of hair behind her ear. “Ice cream sounds nice.”

And for a moment, that was it. Two people, seated across from each other, finding a sliver of light in the leftover pieces of their messy lives. A small moment of ease, of warmth, of maybe.

But outside the café, behind the transparent glass of the front door, Kingsley stood frozen.

He hadn’t left. Not really. After she’d dismissed him again, he’d stepped out, yes—but only to the sidewalk, to the edge of the building. He lingered like a shadow, eyes peeled through the glass. And now he was watching them. Watching her.

His jaw tightened. His eyes narrowed. And there was something burning in his chest—fierce and ugly and green.

Katherine was smiling.

She was laughing.

At him. At someone he didn’t recognize.

Who the hell was he?

Kingsley felt the heat rise up from his collar. His breath went shallow. Katherine never smiled like that anymore—not at him. Not for a long time now.

He turned sharply and walked back toward his black car, yanking the door open with more force than necessary. His driver startled slightly in the front seat but said nothing. Kingsley slid in and slammed the door shut behind him, his fists clenched.

“Drive around the corner,” he muttered. “I need to make a call.”

The car eased off the curb, just enough to disappear from the front view of the café. Kingsley pulled out his phone, scrolled fast, and hit Nathan’s number.

It rang twice.

Then, “Boss?”

Kingsley didn’t waste a second. “There’s someone at the café. A guy. His name is Jordan—or at least that’s what I heard Katherine call him.”

Nathan’s tone was immediately alert. “Jordan?”

“Yeah. He’s not in your report. There was no Jordan in any of the updates. No mention. So who the hell is he?”

“I’ll look into it right away. Might be someone new. I’ll cross-check against her usual contacts, phone logs, and social ties. If he’s relevant, I’ll find him.”

Kingsley exhaled sharply through his nose, staring out the window again. He could still picture her inside—laughing.

“Do that,” he said. Then paused. “And one more thing. I want you to find out where Caroline works.”

“Caroline?”

“Her best friend,” Kingsley said quietly. “Find out what she does, where she goes every day. who she is seeing. I need to be sure Katherine is safe with her”

There was a small pause on the line, and then Nathan’s voice came back, calm and professional. “Understood.”

Kingsley ended the call, his phone still clutched tight in his hand. He looked out at the street, where people passed by with their small, ordinary lives. And there he sat, jaw tight, chest heavy, haunted by something he hadn’t realized until now: he wasn’t ready to let go. Not yet.

Not of Katherine.

And definitely not to someone like Jordan.