Chapter 22

Leo's POV.

I felt her rise from the bed, and instinctively, I reached out to hold her hand. “I like you,” I finally confessed, my voice barely above a whisper.

When I opened my eyes, I met her shocked gaze. Her emerald eyes widened, reflecting disbelief and something more—a fleeting sense of hope? “I like you, Lexi… a lot,” I said, holding her gaze, searching for some spark of understanding in her eyes.

The silence stretched between us like a taut wire. She blinked rapidly, caught off guard. I was expecting a reaction like this. Truth be told, I hadn’t planned to confess my feelings tonight; it just spilled out as if the cosmos aligned for this moment.

“Don’t like me…” she finally spoke. “…because I will never like you,” she added, a harsh finality in her tone.

Her rejection stung harder than I anticipated, but I maintained my composure, refusing to let her see how deeply it affected me.

“Why? Is it because I’m a criminal?” I asked, probing the wound.

“No, that’s not it… It’s not just you. I’ll never like anyone,” she replied, her words coated in a sadness I couldn’t quite comprehend.

“Why?” I probed, unable to let this go.

“Don’t ask me why either,” she shot back, a flicker of pain haunting her eyes before it vanished, leaving me wondering what shadows loomed in her past.

She turned to leave, but I held her wrist gently. “Let go of my hand, Leonardo,” she requested, her voice firm yet betraying a hint of vulnerability.

“Where are you going?” I asked.

“To bed, obviously,” she answered, but it felt like an excuse to escape the moment.

“What’s wrong with this one?” I gestured to the bed I was lying on.

“I can’t share a bed with you, so I’m heading to the other bedroom,” she replied, her resolve hardening.

I pulled her back, and she stumbled slightly, falling onto me. Her eyes went wide as the realization of our position washed over her. “Stop being dramatic. We’ve both done much more than just sharing a bed, remember?" I said.

She raised her fist at me, entirely forgetting that I'm unwell.

I caught her fist mid-air, gently placing her palm against my chest. "Instead of hitting me, why not feel how my heart beats for you?" I suggested, a teasing smile slipping onto my lips.

Her enchanting emerald eyes sparkled with a mix of surprise and something more elusive that made my heart race even faster. Just being near her stirred something deep within me.

"You were actually going to punch me? Did you forget I'm unwell, sweetheart, and that you're the one who's been nursing me back to health?" I chuckled softly, my tone light but my gaze unwavering.

"Well, you certainly don’t look unwell anymore. Honestly, I'm starting to think this was all part of your master plan," she replied, trying to keep her tone stern but I don't think she'll succeed with that.

I leaned in closer, our noses touching. "To be fair, I, too, am surprised by how strong I feel compared to my earlier vegetable state…" I whispered hoarsely, allowing a playful smirk to curve my lips. "I guess you're my strength, baby."

In that moment, I caught the subtle shift in her expression—a quick swallow, a breath hitching in her throat. There it was: the reaction I’d been waiting for.  No one can resist me.

Slowly I reached for her lips and she seemed lost in me already, but just as our lips brushed against each other, she suddenly looked away, voice steady yet laced with resolve. "Don’t waste your time on me, Leonardo. I’ll never reciprocate your feelings," she declared, her finality cutting through the air like a sudden chill.

Before I could respond, she rolled off me, the moment evaporating.

"Goodnight, Leonardo," she said, rising from the bed.

I sighed, correcting her in a softer tone, "It's Leo." But as she walked towards the door, I couldn’t shake the feeling of unfulfilled longing. I take back my words on no woman being able to resist me, this particular one can.

As I watched her silhouette retreat into the shadows, a profound sense of frustration bubbled within me.

"Lexi, wait!" I called out.

She paused at the door, her fingers lingering on the handle, and for a moment, I thought she might turn around. My heart raced with hope, but she didn’t look back. She simply swung the door open and slipped into the hallway.

“Damn it,” I muttered under my breath, feeling the weight of disappointment settle in my chest like a rock. How exactly do I get this girl?

As I pulled the covers right back on myself, she walked back in and my mind lit up again.

"How do you feel?" She asked.

"I like you," I replied and she rolled her eyes.

"Not that, how is your health? Do you feel hot? Cold? Headache? Pains anywhere?" She said.

"Yeah... I think I might go crazy for you, I feel hot from your intoxicating warmth still lingering on my skin, I feel cold from longing for you, my head is in chaos on thoughts about you, and my heart..." I met her gaze. "...my heart is in pain from your harsh rejection of my feelings for you."

She scoffed. "I can see that you're perfectly fine," she said and walked out of the room, leaving me sighing.

The door clicked softly behind her, and I sighed again—this time more heavily. Did she really think that brushing me off was the end of it? I didn't care whether I was physically unwell or not; my heart was in turmoil and I needed to address it.

I pushed myself up against the headboard, determined not to wallow in my disappointment. Lexi was complex; I loved that about her. But I was also infuriated by her stubbornness. How could she deny something so obvious?

Tonight, I had tried to break down her walls, to knock on the door of her heart, even if just to show her that I was not like the others in her life. My instincts told me there was more to her rejection than just a fleeting moment. Yet it felt like every time I attempted to get closer, she pulled away like she was afraid of getting burned.

I slid out of bed and padded quietly towards the door. There was no way I was letting Lexi settle into the other room without at least giving this another shot. I wasn’t going to let fear or her walls dictate our future.

Opening the door, I peered into the dim hallway. The light from the room spilled out, illuminating the small space. I walked to the next door opposite and gave a knock.

"What now, Leonardo?" I heard her exasperated response.

"Can we talk?" I asked.

"No!" I heard her firm response. "I have to go to work tomorrow, Leonardo, so please let me sleep in peace," she added.

"I promise it'll be short," I insisted.

In a few seconds, the door opened and her frowning face came in view. I had to press my lips to make sure I don't laugh.

"Thank you, that's what I wanted to say... thank you for nursing me," I said sincerely.

"That's it?" She raised a brow like she was expecting more.

"You were expecting something more?" I asked.

"Thought it was even something important," she muttered to herself but I heard it.

"Goodnight then," I said and quickly planted a small kiss on her cheek and ran off.

"Hey!" I heard her yell as I went into the previous room, chuckling.