Chapter 43

Chapter 43:

Gina POV

“You’re Diane,” I breathed, my composure slipping for half a second.

She smiled, just barely. “So the rumors were true. You’ve been busy.”

I forced a polite, almost mocking chuckle. “I’ve heard about you. But I didn’t realize you were still around.”

“Oh, I never left,” she replied smoothly. “I just stopped being visible. Makes it easier to watch people like you work.”

I straightened. “Well, unless you’ve bumped into me to offer skincare tips or borrow a lighter, I’m not sure what this is about.”

Diane stepped closer, eyes narrowed. “Don’t play coy, Gina. You’ve been pulling strings like a shadow puppeteer. But puppets tend to tangle… and when they do, they break.”

There was a silence between us so thick you could cut it with a diamond.

I recovered with a slow, cold smile. “If you’ve got something to say, say it. I don’t play well with cryptic threats.”

“Oh, it’s not a threat,” she said, her tone almost amused. “It’s a promise.”

And just like that, she turned on her heel and walked away.

I stood there for a moment, blinking the surprise out of my system.

Diane. That Diane. The ex who had nearly ruined Kane, the one who’d vanished after her father’s scandal, and the one person I never thought would resurface in this chessboard of moves I’d so carefully orchestrated.

Well. Things just got interesting.

And a whole lot messier.

The cab hummed softly as the city blurred past the window, rain streaking down like lazy tears. I leaned back against the seat, eyes half-lidded, mind running laps around everything that had just gone down.

Caroline had sounded… drained. Not heartbroken exactly, but like a woman trying to bury a storm under a calm surface. She was always the quiet storm type, never the explosion, always the slow burn. It was why I’d picked her.

Yes, picked. Because contrary to what Kane believed, their meeting hadn’t been accidental. I’d introduced Caroline to him, nudged them toward each other, lit the fire and stepped back to watch it catch. It was all part of the plan…. my grand plan.

But even I hadn’t anticipated how real the sparks would get. Or how messy it would become.

I checked my phone again. One new message from an unknown number. I didn’t open it. Not yet.

Instead, I pulled out a compact mirror and touched up my lipstick. A war might’ve been brewing behind the scenes, but appearances? Always mattered.

Forty minutes later, the cab pulled up in front of a quiet brownstone in Philadelphia. Her place. Cozy, dimly lit, with curtains that looked like they were hiding secrets.

I paid the driver and stepped out, heels clicking softly on the wet sidewalk. A few steps later, I was at her door, pressing the buzzer.

No response.

I buzzed again, more insistently this time.

Finally, a voice crackled through the intercom. “You didn’t bring snacks, did you?”

“I brought wine,” I said. “And questionable life choices.”

The lock buzzed. I smiled.

As I climbed the stairs to the third floor, my heels echoing in the stairwell, I allowed myself a rare, honest moment of uncertainty.

Kane was unraveling.

Caroline was slipping.

And me? I was right in the middle of a game I started… but might no longer fully control.

Still if the board was tilting, I was going to make damn sure I landed on my feet.

Caroline's POV

I let her in without another word.

Moments later, the door swung open and in walked Gina Smith with her coat soaked from the rain, heels still intact, and not a single strand of hair out of place. She dropped a bottle of wine and two chocolate bars on the coffee table like she was performing some kind of pagan healing ritual.

“You look like the tragic heroine in one of those French movies where no one smiles and everyone smokes,” she said, kicking off her heels. “Except you’re prettier, and this apartment smells like lavender instead of cigarettes and despair.”

I snorted. “Thanks, I guess.”

She plopped down beside me and handed me a glass of wine like it was a prescription. “So. The idiot still got you crying?”

“No,” I muttered. “I’m not crying.”

Gina gave me a look. “Please. Your eyes are puffy, your mascara’s on your chin, and you answered the intercom like a war widow.”

That got a real laugh out of me. A small one but real.

“That’s better,” she grinned. “Now drink. You look like you’re one rejection away from starting a cult.”

We drank in silence for a moment.

Then she added, “For the record, if you do start a cult, I’m in. But only if I get to be the one with the cool cloak and ceremonial dagger.”

“You’re insane,” I said, laughing again.

“And you love me.”

I didn’t reply. But she wasn’t wrong.

I leaned my head against her shoulder, the warmth of the wine softening the edge of everything. And for the first time all day, I didn’t feel entirely alone.

“Maybe you should marry me,” Gina teased. “We'd take care of the babies together.”

I chuckled. “I'll think about it.”

For a moment I saw Gina give a satisfied smirk then she just changed it back to a smile.

It disturbed me but I let it go. I was probably being paranoid.

Gina's POV

Caroline sipped her wine, curled on the couch in one of my oversized hoodies like the world hadn’t tried to ruin her earlier this morning. I was making her laugh because if there was one thing I was good at, it was finding something dark and inappropriate to say in moments like these.

Then she looked at me with those damn eyes of hers, tired, soft, searching and it hit me all over again. The ache. The secret. The thing she still didn’t know.

I glanced at my wine glass, smirked, and said, “You know, I still remember the day I met you. And no, it wasn’t because of your charming disdain for overpriced poetry.”

She raised a brow. “Wasn’t that the bookstore party?”

“Oh, it was,” I said, swirling my drink. “But you remember it for the snacks and awkward small talk. I remember it like an origin story.”

I’d just landed in the city. Fresh from an exhausting breakup, clinging to my last shred of ambition and a fake confidence I wore like lipstick. My editor dragged me to a book launch, a poetry collection I never bothered reading and I was about five seconds from setting the place on fire for being so boring.

And then she walked in.

Caroline.

Wearing an old leather jacket and a smirk like she owned the place. She laughed at something the bartender said, and the sound made me stop mid-sip. Just… stopped me.

Not because she was the most beautiful woman in the room though, objectively, she was but because she looked untouched. Effortlessly whole. Like nothing the world threw at her could stick for long.

I stared too long and convinced myself it was admiration.

An Inspiration. A fascination with her vibe. But it wasn’t. Not really.

I fell. Quietly. Immediately. And entirely.

Of course, I never told her. Why ruin a perfectly good friendship with the truth?

The truth that I was inlove with her.