Chapter 3: Craig

“Mine?” Craig’s heart raced. He looked between Nadine and the child, not knowing where to focus his attention. The baby was small—he had to be close to newly born. “What do you mean?”

He hadn’t slept with Nadine, not ever. Craig had been in a relationship with her sister, Synthia, for a few years, but he’d finally left when he realized that a few drinks on the weekends had turned into toxic alcoholism.

“Synthia was pregnant when you left her,” Nadine said.

Craig bit down on his jaw and tried to process everything he was feeling. His first instinct was to deny, but the dates added up a little too well. After they’d broken up, he’d slept with Synthia one last time in some of the hottest breakup sex he’d ever had. In the heat of the moment, they hadn’t used a condom.

Shit.

“Craig?” his mother asked, incredulous.

“I…” Craig rubbed his arm. He’d met Cecilia no more than a week later, and four months into their relationship, he’d proposed. He had no clue that Synthia was pregnant. She hadn’t ever reached out to let him know. “I didn’t know.”

“You’re not denying it!” his mother squeaked.

“The dates add up,” Craig admitted with a shrug. “We’ll have DNA testing done to see, but… I think he is.”

“I don’t really have any reason to lie to you,” Nadine said. “Whatever beef you and Synthia had, that’s not on me. All I know is that I have a nephew who needs his daddy, and you’re it.”

Craig heard the click of Cecilia’s heels as she approached. This wasn’t going to end well.

“I don’t understand why you’re approaching me,” Craig admitted. “Why isn’t Synthia stepping forward?”

“She’s been in rehab,” Nadine admitted. “When she found out she was pregnant she checked herself in and she’s been sober all through her stay. Isaac is healthy. But right now, she’s not at a place in her recovery where she’s ready to be released yet. She went into rehab because she knew she had to be healthy for Isaac, not because she wanted to be healthy for herself. Until that changes, she’s barred from the outside world, and Isaac needs someone to take care of him.”

“And I take it you don’t want that responsibility,” Craig murmured.

Nadine’s eyes hardened. “Listen,” she said. “I love this little boy. I might not know him very well, but I love him. If I were in any kind of position where I could keep him, I would. But why would I deprive him of the life he could have if he were to be with you? Money. A house to grow up in. Brand new baby clothes and toys instead of cheap second-hand knockoffs. I love him enough to know that he deserves to be with you because I want him to have the best life he can.”

A baby. Craig’s gaze held fast on Isaac.

He’d helped make another person.

The feeling was surreal.

Even though Isaac wasn’t planned, and Craig knew that his existence was going to throw his life into chaos, he felt himself falling in love. A baby. It felt like a chance to start fresh—a shot at a new family that would love him for who he was instead of what he could offer.

Craig’s mother didn’t feel this same way.

“This is ridiculous,” she exclaimed loudly. “Utterly ridiculous. You expect us to believe that this child belongs to Craig?”

“Well… yeah,” Nadine said flatly. She hadn’t ever been one to take bullshit. “He is. Whether you like it or not, your son was dating my sister. It’s not like this is coming out of the blue. It was an established relationship.”

“This is a ploy for money,” Craig’s mother accused.

“Uh. No. Having a baby is expensive. Do you think Synthia is stupid enough that she’d forget you’d demand DNA testing? She’s not trying to con you into paying child support. All I want is for Craig to step up and be a dad while she’s in rehab. That’s all.”

A dad. He was a dad. Craig beamed.

Cecilia’s nails dug into his shoulder. “Craig?” she asked through gritted teeth. “What the hell is this?”

“This is my son,” Craig said. “Isaac.”

Isaac. Craig’s heart fluttered. He’d never thought of being a father before, but now that he’d been dragged headfirst into parenthood, he couldn’t help but be glad. In fact, the last time he was this happy he’d been out in North Carolina palling around with Lane’s friends.

Joking with Jack.

Craig shrugged away from Cecilia’s touch, stepping out onto the front step to stand beside Nadine. Isaac squirmed in her arms; his tiny eyes closed. A tuft of pale hair stuck out from beneath the blanket he was wrapped in. It looked white in the light.

“Can I hold him?” Craig asked.

“You’ll do no such thing!” Craig’s mother squawked. “You’re not to touch it until we know for sure if it’s yours!”

The downy excitement in Craig’s chest dissipated. In its place spread ice. Craig glared at his mother, hackles up. “Isaac isn’t an it,” he uttered. “He’s a little boy, and no matter who his father is, he deserves your respect. He’s a living human being, Mother.”

“And you will not touch him,” she insisted. At her side, Cecilia stood tall and indignant, her eyes narrowed and threatening. Craig wasn’t going to let either of them scare him away from taking care of his child.

He had no proof other than his gut feeling, but he knew Isaac was his.

“You want to hold him?” Nadine asked, unfazed by the attitudes of the women who stood behind Craig. “He’s still little. You need to make sure you support his head.”

Craig knew nothing about babies, and as Nadine laid Isaac in his arms, he started to panic. There was so much he knew he didn’t know that he was sure he was going to make a mistake. What if he didn’t support his head enough? What if he needed to be burped? Babies needed to be burped, right? How would he know?

“Look,” Nadine said with a gentle smile. “He looks good on you. What a proud papa.”

“He is not the father,” Craig’s mother admonished.

“Well. Whatever. Not like we can’t get the receipts easily enough.” Nadine shrugged. “If you’re so sure he isn’t the father, then get a paternity test done. It’s as simple as that.”

“We will.” It was Cecilia’s shrill voice that promised it. Craig couldn’t even bring himself to look at her. He cradled Isaac in one arm and traced a finger down his little button nose. It was smaller than his pinkie. How could a person be so small?

“I have his supplies in the car,” Nadine said. She made a face. “Security wouldn’t let me bring it up to the front door. What the hell do you think I’m going to do with some jars of strained peas and a bunch of onesies? So ridiculous.”

“Let’s go get it together,” Craig said. He made sure Isaac was tucked firmly into the crook of his arm. He fit so naturally there that it nearly brought tears to Craig’s eyes. He was a dad. “Are you really giving him to me? I… I don’t have any experience. I don’t think we even have baby furniture.”

“That baby is not coming into this house,” Craig’s mother said.

Craig looked over his shoulder at the doorway. His mother blocked the entrance, her arms crossed. Behind her, Cecilia glared daggers in Craig’s direction.

“I guess I’ll go home then,” Craig said. If he stayed, then what? He’d never hear the end of it from his mother or from Cecilia, and he’d rather spend time with Isaac than either of them. “Change of plans, Nadine. I’ll meet you beyond the gates with my car and we can get Isaac settled. Do you want to take him back so I can drive up to meet you?”

“Craig!” Cecilia cried. “This is insanity! You need to stop right now! These people are trying to take you from me!”

“Right.” Nadine gave her a sarcastic look. “Because the only thing I live for is to see my sister’s ex’s relationships destroyed. What an exciting life I must lead.”

Cecilia glowered at her. Nadine rolled her eyes and shook her head. She took Isaac from Craig’s arms, and Craig was surprised to find that he missed the feeling of having Isaac close.

It had only been a few minutes, but he was already smitten.

“I’ll meet you up front, Craig,” Nadine said. She wound back down the steps and along the driveway to the front gates dividing the property from the rest of the world. “Thanks for not being a total asshat about this.”

Craig snickered. “You’re welcome.”

He followed her down the stairs, diverging to get his car from the garage. He’d driven Cecilia here, but she could find her own way home. Maybe his mother would drive her, since the two of them got along so well. Both of them had lost his respect after the antics they’d just pulled.

Isaac was a baby. He didn’t deserve such hostility.

Craig was vaguely aware that his mother and Cecilia were calling after him, but he didn’t stop. He let himself into the garage, opened his car door, and settled into the driver’s seat.

There were bigger things to worry about than lace tablecloths and centerpiece selections. Craig had a new life to get situated and to care for. A new life that depended on him.

And in a strange way, despite the responsibility that came with being a parent, Craig had never felt so free.