Chapter 89: Chapter Twenty-Two: We Fall, We Fight, We Figure It Out-2

Zoe shrugged and looked toward the living room where Alex and the guys were. “It explains why I don’t catch you looking at him with that sparkle in your eye. Or why you don’t absently reach out to touch him just because subconsciously, you can’t stand to be too far from him. Those little things that tell you all you need to know about how someone feels.” “Sometimes, those little things come with time, with feeling that way about the person,” I said, sighing in resignation because Zoe was right. “Sometimes, it’s not instantaneously magical.” “Sometimes, it’s only possible when you’re not already in love with someone else,” Zoe supplied without any pretense. She turned to me with a small, understanding smile. “I just thought that when it came down to it, for a smart, sensible girl like you, it would be a no-brainer between Alex Rizzo and Luke Hedenby.” I opened my mouth to feign innocence about Luke but then remembered what she knew. Right. “Luke’s the kind of guy a girl wants to date at some point in her life, just for the fun of it, ” Zoe continued. “Alex is the kind of guy you take home to meet your parents and marry at the town church.” “And what makes you think that there’s a choice I need to be making here?” I asked, slumping against the counter with my arms crossed and staring at the same smiling man that Zoe was. She didn’t glance my way but I couldn’t miss the steel in her statement. “I definitely hope there is because no one wants to be the second best thing. The consolation prize. The one you settled with because you couldn’t have the other. You get the point.” “It’s not fair, I know,” I agreed softly, watching Alex and wondering if the time would ever come when I would look inside my heart and find him there instead of the one who broke it. The thought took root in my mind and didn’t leave for the rest of the evening, long after the party cleared out and he and I were left cleaning up. Jillian and I were leaving together but she was in Alex’s office, setting up his entire home network to control all the wired-in enhancements from the balcony lights to the built-in speaker system to the wine cooler to the heated floors. He hadn't even known the place came with it when he got it and when Jillian pleaded if she could please, please, do it, he just shrugged and told her to knock herself out. I was drying my hands by the kitchen sink when I felt strong arms wrap around me from behind. "Have I said thank you yet?" Alex asked and he gave me a light squeeze of a hug before loosening his hold so I could turn around and face him. "What for? The party?" I asked. "I helped you shop for stuff and set it up but the credit should really go to Zoe. She had this party planned out to the most minute detail halfway through her small, non-fat latte.” "And I will thank her for it," he said, not quite letting go. "But I owe you for having stuck with me these past few weeks. For being a good friend. For being here tonight.” I smiled despite the guilty reminder that I’d wavered on my promise, even just mentally, to spare myself the torture of having a dream that would never come true dangled right before my eyes. “I’m where the cool people are at.” Alex grinned. “I owe you, too, for making me smile all the time. For trusting me to make you smile as well. For letting me in, even just a little bit." His gaze on me was soft and smiling, his arms warm and secure around me. This is what it should be like. And it could be like this. If I could only want it. I knew even before Alex took in a deep breath that he was going to kiss me. And I closed my eyes because I wanted to know if there was the slightest chance that I wasn't being unfair to him. That I wasn't settling with the safe choice. That I wasn't leading him down a road that went nowhere. That somewhere inside of me, I wanted this. That I wanted him. His lips brushed so fleetingly against mine at first I thought it was just his breath, warm and teasing as he closed every excruciating inch between us to make that first shy contact. But when I felt the slightest increased pressure, it hit me that Alex was, in fact, kissing me. It was at first a collection of small, gentle kisses dotted all over the shape of my mouth—an invitation to trust, to let go a little and to let him in more. My heart squeezed at that because it was so like Alex to never take more than what I could give. And I want to give more. I wanted to give him all that Luke wouldn’t take because the longer I held it in, the sooner it would burst from under my skin. My own lips started to move—kissing him back, letting him in, giving him more. His arms tightened around me, pulling me close, and my own glided up over his chest until they linked behind his neck. Warmth bloomed inside of me, filling all the places that had been left cold and empty when Luke had backed away for good. I clung to it as an addict might to their first faint vestiges of clarity and lightness that hadn’t come from a pill or powder. I waited for the instant transformation, when I no longer felt cold and burdened, as if this kiss just might be a magical cure, but as Alex deepened it, the only thing that transformed was the face in my head. I kept seeing those bright winter blue eyes—sparkling with amusement, darkening with desire, catching light like shards from a broken soul—and the warmth receded. In fact, I felt colder than I ever did before, knowing deep in my bones that while my body could stir at intimacy in general, my heart and mind knew too well what it wanted and didn’t have—and a substitute made the loss sharper. Luke didn’t need to ask me not to be with Alex. I’m doing that on my own right now.