Chapter 80: Chapter Twenty: Cards Down, Walls Up-4
“So, what do you say?” I asked with less bravado than I originally had, wondering if I really even wanted to hear his answer at this point, knowing what it was going to be. When he didn’t answer, I nudged his leg with my foot. “Hey. Are you even listening to me?” He glanced at me, his face anxious. “I have things to straighten out with Lola so she leaves me alone for good. As for Elise, I have to see her. But it’s not something you have to worry about.” That he was already clammed up shut about Elise, as if that explanation was good enough and final, just made me unravel so much more inside. I could only guess so much about where I stood, making assumptions and getting no reassurances. As far as compromises go, it sucked. If I was reaching out, I’d like for him to at least take my hand instead of shrinking away and shutting me out. “So when I tell you that the afternoon I’ve planned with Alex shouldn’t be something you have to worry about, you’ll believe me, right?” I asked with a tight smile. Luke looked like he was mashing his teeth behind his granite scowl. “I can’t ignore the obvious fact that he’s male enough to see what I don’t want him looking at.” Tears—of frustration and a fragile sort of sadness at the realization that this cycle with Luke might never end and we’d never be more or less than what we were now—pricked my eyes and I quickly blinked them back. “You know you’re not being fair, right?” I said with a voice I wished came out steadier. An intense light flickered in Luke’s eyes that for a moment, I wondered if they were getting as glassy as mine probably were. “No, I’m not.” And even though I already knew that, apparently, I could still be reckless enough to invite more pain. “Cards on the table, Luke. If you want me, you’ll have me. But I’ve got to have you, too.” His lips disappeared into a thin line, his chin betraying just the slightest quiver. “I can’t make you happy, Max, and that’s the only thing I want you to be.” “You won’t know until you try.” “That’s exactly what I’m trying to do right now and look at the fantastic fuck-up of a job I’m doing with it,” he countered in a harsh, desperate tone that had me backing up a step. “So that’s it,” I said. “You can’t be with me. And no one else can either.” He reached for me and laced his fingers through my stiff, trembling ones. “Is it too selfish of me to ask you not to be with him?” I bit the inside of my lower lip and wrenched my hand out of his grasp. “Yes, Luke, it is. If you don’t think you’re the right person to make someone happy, giving someone else the chance is the least you can do.” He gazed at me for what could’ve been the length of a heartbeat or the infinity of a moment that would never be before he briefly closed his eyes and exhaled deeply. He didn’t look at me then. Whatever he was looking at wasn’t the thing he wanted—that much I could tell because he looked like he’d just been handed a death sentence—but he was resigned to his fate, possibly even determined about it. “Then you should probably go if you don’t want to be late.” His voice was soft—like snow steadily falling until it froze the earth. God, it hurt. It hurt to be broken inside, to have to stand there and let the pieces be until you were alone—until there was no one else to see you on your knees putting the pieces back together through the blur of tears and humiliation. “Will you promise me something?” This time, the tears slipped down my cheeks and I dashed them back angrily. Luke lifted his eyes to me, his profile so sharp and flinty it could’ve been carved out of stone. “What is it, Max?” I curled my fists at my sides, summoning all the strength and dignity from every cell in my body. “That this is where we draw the hard line—and you’re never to cross it again.” Only his beautiful blue eyes—shimmering like shattered glass catching the sun—indicated the storm brewing inside of him. “I know I should stay away from you and I’m sorry that I couldn’t—that I still can’t. I never meant to hurt you, Max.” I squared my shoulders—perhaps I didn’t want to be any weaker or more vulnerable than I already was around him—but it was an effort that cost me no small amount of pain. I smiled at the irony of it all. “Isn’t it funny how you think you can hurt someone with a choice when in the end you hurt them more by not having one?” Since I’d taken about as much as I could without crumpling to the floor, I turned and walked to the bedroom to change and collect my things. Luke stayed in the living room, saying and doing nothing as I packed up to leave, his head buried in his hands. We’d been through a few of these before—the irresistible pull and the inevitable push—but today the distance felt real and measurable and vast. The music had crested and we’d finally started spinning fast, heads buzzing, hearts pounding. It would seem, after all that mad dancing, we’d spun apart as fast as we’d tumbled into it the first time. And now we would walk away from each other, uncertain of our injuries but knowing that we bled anyway. I left a different person from the one who came last night. Somehow, for all my sterling efforts to avoid complications that led to a broken heart, I managed to achieve just that. My first mistake was to think that Luke was going to be different—that he wasn’t going to see me that way, that we were going to be just friends, that it wouldn’t become more than that, that I could protect my heart just fine even with him so close. My second mistake was to think that we could recover from the first—that we could overcome our fears, that we could accept our new and unexpected path, that we could trust each other enough to go down that road, that maybe we could be happy together. I didn’t want a third mistake but then it may not matter much at this point. There was nothing left to break. ***