Chapter 49
Carl’s POV
I gazed down at Lina's sleeping form, taking a deep breath as I tried to process everything that had happened tonight. The tequila and the feel of her body against mine had pushed the evening in a direction I hadn't initially planned for, though I certainly wasn't objecting to having her in my bed.
For so long, I'd held back because I suspected she wouldn't respond well to my particular tastes in the bedroom. As it turned out, I was completely wrong. She had embraced it like a natural, and that was only scratching the surface of what I enjoyed.
The dim light of my phone illuminated the darkness of my bedroom. Looking over to where it lay on the nightstand, I saw my pack's intelligence officer's name appear on the screen.
"Hello?" I whispered as I quietly closed the bedroom door behind me.
"Alpha Carl, I apologize for calling at this hour, but we have a lead on Ara."
My pulse quickened. "What have you got?"
"He's been spotted at Moana Azure near the beach. Our sources indicate he's still there, drinking alone at the bar. He's been there for almost three hours now."
I straightened immediately. "That's just down the coast from where Lina and I had dinner."
"Yes, sir. We believe he may have seen you there and followed your scent before settling at Moana Azure."
"Keep your distance but maintain surveillance. I'll handle this personally."
After ending the call, I glanced back at Lina's sleeping form. She looked peaceful, her chest rising and falling with slow, steady breaths. Earlier tonight, before falling asleep, she had knelt by the window, whispering a prayer to the Moon Goddess, asking for her blessing to find Ara and bring him back safely. The sincerity in her voice had touched something deep within me.
I quickly scribbled a note explaining I had stepped out and left it on the nightstand beside her phone. Then I slipped out of the villa and into the warm Hawaiian night.
The restaurant was perched on a cliff edge, its open-air design offering stunning views of the moonlit waves below. Tiki torches cast a warm glow over the wooden deck, and the gentle sounds of ukulele music drifted through the air. And there he was—sitting alone at the far end of the bar, hunched over what appeared to be whiskey. His normally pristine appearance had given way to disheveled clothes and several days' worth of stubble. But there was no mistaking him. Ara, my youngest brother, the one who had formed the deepest connection with Lina from the start.
"Well, well," I said quietly, sliding onto the barstool beside him. "Fancy seeing you here."
Ara turned slowly, his bloodshot eyes meeting mine with a mixture of anger and resignation. "How did you find me?"
"My pack has eyes everywhere. Especially when I'm looking for someone important."
He scoffed, downing the remainder of his whiskey in one gulp. "I've been careful."
"Not careful enough." I signaled the bartender for two drinks. "You were watching us earlier tonight, weren't you? At the restaurant."
Ara's jaw tightened. "So what if I was?"
"So what do you want?" His voice was rough from alcohol and disuse.
"Come back with me. Lina's asleep at the villa. See her for yourself."
The whiskey glass in Ara's hand shattered, causing nearby patrons to turn their heads. His eyes flashed dangerously, hints of gold appearing in his irises.
"You want me to just come back? After what you did?" His voice was low but filled with venom. "You manipulated all of us. You convinced us to leave her when she needed us most."
I maintained my composure. "Let's take this outside."
On the restaurant's rear deck, with the waves crashing against the cliffs below, Ara unleashed his fury.
"You had no right," he growled, getting in my face. "No fucking right to make that decision for all of us. Every day without her has been torture. Do you have any idea what it's like to feel half-dead? To wake up every morning with her scent still haunting you?"
"I know," I said quietly.
"No, you don't know!" He shoved me hard, sending me back a step. "You didn't have the bond we had. You didn't feel it tear apart. You didn't feel your wolf howling every night for its mate!"
My patience snapped. I grabbed him by the collar and slammed him against the railing. "Don't pretend you're the only one who suffered! I watched her wake up alone and confused. I saw the pain in her eyes when she realized you were all gone. I stayed to face her questions, her tears, her anger—while you were drowning in self-pity!"
"Because you told me to leave!" he roared, breaking my grip. "You said it was what was best for her!"
"And I was wrong!" The admission burned more than whiskey ever could. My mind drifted back to that fateful day at FaunaSphere Dynamics when everything changed. The three brothers hadn't left Lina because of the physical discomfort of a broken bond, as I'd later claimed to her. No, we'd made a pact to protect her from our world.
"If you loved her at all, you would let her go," I had told Ara in the hospital hallway. "She deserves a normal life away from all this supernatural danger!"
I had convinced them that our presence would only bring her more pain, more risk. Devin and Barry had reluctantly agreed, but Ara had been the hardest to convince. His bond with her had been the strongest, the first to form.
Now, on this moonlit deck, I finally confessed the truth. "I fucked up. I made a terrible mistake, and I've been trying to fix it ever since."
Ara paced like a caged animal, running his hands through his hair. "And now you expect me to just follow you back to her like nothing happened? To forget that you manipulated all of us? That you lied to her face every day since?"
"No," I said more calmly. "I expect you to do what's best for Lina. Not what's best for me, or even what's best for you—but what's best for her."
"And what is that?"
"She wants all of us. The Moon Goddess changed the terms of the bond. It's her choice now—and she's chosen to have all four of us."
Ara stopped pacing, looking at me with suspicion. "That's not possible."
"Gran confirmed it. The Goddess favors her." I took a step toward him, keeping my voice level. "She's been searching for you for weeks, Ara. She crossed an ocean to find you. What does that tell you?"
A long silence stretched between us, broken only by the sound of the waves. Finally, Ara leaned against the railing, his anger seeming to drain out of him.
"If you're lying to me again..." he began.
"I'm not. Come see for yourself."
"And if I do? What then?"
"Then you make your own choice. But she deserves to see you face to face, to hear whatever you decide directly from you."
He stared out at the moonlit ocean, his internal struggle evident. The pull of the bond battled with his distrust of me.
"Fine," he said at last, his voice rough with emotion. "I'll come with you. But I'm not promising anything."
I nodded, relief flooding through me. As we walked back through the restaurant, I saw the determination in his eyes. Whether he admitted it or not, he had already made his decision.
The game of separation was over. It was time to reunite what fate had bound together.