Chapter 86
Elena's POV
I watched with satisfaction as my family finished the meal I'd prepared. The meat broth noodles had been a hit—Max was already on his second helping, and Richard had cleaned his plate without complaint. Kathy and Lily had emptied their bowls too.
"Is everyone finished?" I asked, gathering empty dishes.
"That was so yummy, Mommy!" Lily exclaimed, patting her little tummy with exaggerated contentment. She turned to her sister with bright eyes. "Kathy, isn't Mom's noodle soup delicious?"
"It's good," she finally said, her voice quiet but clear. "Better than at home."
My heart swelled. From Kathy, this simple statement was the highest praise. I caught Richard's subtle reaction—a slight raise of his eyebrow.
"What about you, Daddy?" Lily turned her attention to Richard. "Isn't Mommy's cooking the best in the world?"
Richard's stern expression made Lily shrink back slightly. I held my breath, preparing to intervene if necessary, but he simply cleared his throat.
"It's satisfactory," he said, his tone measured.
Coming from him, such an evaluation indicated he was quite pleased with the meal. I smiled as I collected the dishes and headed to the kitchen. While washing up, I contemplated how to broach the subject of Kathy staying overnight. Richard had been surprisingly civil during dinner, but I knew how protective he was of Kathy. Asking for an overnight stay might be pushing too far.
I dried the last plate, my mind made up. I grabbed an apple from the fruit bowl, deciding to have Kathy convince him. "Kathy," I called softly.
Kathy looked up from the book Lily was showing her and walked over.
"I've already decided you're staying here tonight, but we should let your father know. Could you take this apple to your dad and mention it to him? Okay?"
She nodded and walked toward Richard.
Be brave, sweetheart. Ask him to let you stay.
I busied myself wiping counters, straining to hear their conversation while pretending not to.
Richard's POV
I watched Elena collect the dishes with practiced efficiency. The children migrated to the living room.
I hadn't expected to enjoy dinner. I certainly hadn't expected Elena to know about my seafood allergy.
Was it really Anna who told her?
As Elena disappeared into the kitchen, I found myself wandering toward her bedroom, where a notebook lay open on a desk. The handwriting was unmistakably Elena's—that neat, flowing script. I found myself staring at it, a sense of familiarity washing over me. I felt like I'd seen this handwriting somewhere before.
I was so lost in thought that I barely noticed Kathy approaching until she stood right beside me.
"Dad, what are you doing?" she asked, interrupting my thoughts. She held out an apple.
I accepted the fruit, studying my daughter's face. She seemed different here—more relaxed, more like a child.
"Nothing," I finally said. "Just looking."
We returned to the living room, Kathy following behind as if she had something else to say.
Kathy took a deep breath, her small shoulders squaring with determination. "Dad, can I ask you something?"
I gave her my full attention, waiting.
"I don't want to leave you," she began, the words tumbling out faster than usual. "But I want to spend more time with Mom. Could I... could I stay here tonight?"
I looked down at Kathy, who was still waiting for my answer.
"You want to stay overnight?" I asked quietly.
She nodded, her eyes hopeful.
I glanced toward where Max and Lily were playing, then toward the kitchen where I could sense Elena had been eavesdropping. When Kathy just asked if she could stay overnight, my first instinct was to refuse. I didn't know why I felt this way.
When did I start disliking Elena?
The question arose unbidden. I was ten when our fathers first introduced us. Elena's father and mine, though from different wolf packs, had developed a friendship through business dealings. Despite belonging to different territories, they'd grown close enough to arrange a marriage between their children.
I didn't understand what marriage meant then. I only knew that six-year-old Elena followed me everywhere, just like Lily does now—innocent, trusting, someone I barely knew.
Then came my early awakening. My wolf emerged years before it should have, leaving me unable to control the shift. During one episode, I lost control completely and killed a neighbor's dog. Elena witnessed it all, her eyes wide with terror.
Like any frightened child would, she told her parents. But the consequences were severe. I was deemed dangerous, unstable. For years afterward, I was confined to our property by my father, unable to go out, and subjected to rigorous daily training to control my shifts. Those years of isolation and harsh discipline shaped me—hardened me and made me solitary.
I blamed Elena for all of it.
Yet during those painful years, I constantly received letters from the same person, with candy tucked inside the envelopes. The letters were always filled with encouraging words and interesting stories from the outside world. These kept me company.
By the time our arranged marriage was formalized, my resentment had calcified into hatred. I couldn't defy my Alpha father, but I made sure Elena knew how much I resisted our marriage.
When I received those reply letters from Victoria, I believed she was the girl who had kept me company during my most difficult times. And I fulfilled the promise in the letters to take care of her for life. I brought Victoria home with me. That was the beginning of the breakdown in my relationship with Elena.
But just now, seeing her handwriting on the desk, I felt a deep sense of familiarity. An incredible thought kept nagging at my mind. I needed more evidence.
After a long moment of consideration, I nodded. "I understand. I'll come pick you up tomorrow."
The surprise and joy that transformed her face was worth whatever discomfort I felt at leaving her here. "Really?"
"Yes," I confirmed.
I watched as she ran to Elena, excitement radiating from her in a way I rarely witnessed.
Elena's POV
I was still pretending to clean the kitchen when Kathy burst in, her face alight with excitement.
"Mom! Dad said I can stay overnight!" she exclaimed, bouncing on her toes.
For a moment, I thought I'd misheard. "He did?"
"Yes! He said he'll pick me up tomorrow."
I could hardly believe it. Richard was actually letting Kathy stay? I glanced toward him, catching his eye across the room. His expression was unreadable, but he nodded once, confirming what Kathy had said.
After sending her back to her siblings with the good news, I approached Richard cautiously, still not quite believing his decision.
"You're really okay with her staying overnight?" I asked, unable to keep the surprise from my voice.
"Yes."
I wasn't sure what had prompted this unexpected generosity, but I wasn't about to question it. "Thank you," I said simply.
He nodded once, then bent slightly to address Kathy, who had come running back with Max and Lily. "Behave yourself. I'll see you tomorrow."
His hand rested briefly on her head—a rare display of affection that made my heart clench. Then he was gone, the door closing quietly behind him.
For a moment, we all stood frozen in disbelief. Then Max broke the silence.
"Did that actually happen? Is Kathy really staying?"
I nodded, still stunned. "Yes, she is."
The apartment erupted in cheers. Max and Lily jumped up and down, pulling Kathy into an impromptu dance around the living room. Even Kathy, usually so reserved, was laughing. I joined them, relief and joy washing over me in waves.