Chapter 16: Pretend
~Ava~
Logan's words were still echoing in my mind as I walked to the library, the sound of the soft click of my sneakers on the tile floor almost comforting in its simplicity. He’d told me he’d pick me up after practice. He’d told me. I hadn’t even asked. And part of me loved it, the part that wanted to believe that maybe, just maybe, he liked spending time with me beyond just our tutoring sessions.
I had to shake the thought away. Focus. Focus on the tutoring. That’s what this was about. Helping him with his grades. Nothing more.
But then, why did the idea of him picking me up make my heart skip a beat? Why did the idea of spending time with him outside of the classroom have me in a frenzy? I’d told myself, after our study sessions, after that kiss in the library—the kiss, that we could just go back to normal. Friends. Nothing more. And yet, with each passing moment, the line between what I wanted and what I was willing to admit to myself became blurrier.
By the time I reached the library, I was already feeling overwhelmed with a mix of emotions I wasn’t prepared to deal with. My thoughts scattered and my chest tight, I tried to focus on what was in front of me—my textbook and notes, Logan’s smiling face. He was waiting for me at the door, leaning casually against the frame of the library entrance, looking completely at ease, as if nothing had changed between us. But I couldn’t shake the tension building up inside me.
“Hey,” Logan greeted me, his voice warm and easy. I forced a smile, though it felt stiff on my lips.
“Hey,” I replied, voice a little too high-pitched. He raised an eyebrow at me, but didn’t say anything about it.
“I finished practice early. You ready to go?” he asked.
I nodded, though I could already feel my nerves creeping up. “Yeah, let’s go.”
He pushed himself off the doorframe and walked beside me toward the parking lot. His presence was so natural, so comfortable, yet my heart was racing for reasons I couldn’t explain.
We didn’t talk much during the short drive. Logan had a way of making silence feel natural. The sound of the radio filled the space between us, but it wasn’t uncomfortable. Just… there. Like this quiet understanding.
When we finally pulled up to the diner, Logan turned to me with that ever-familiar grin. “I need your help with something. I know it’s a little last minute, but would you mind pretending to be my girlfriend for a night?”
I froze, my heart dropping into my stomach. “Wait… what?”
Logan let out a small laugh, rubbing the back of his neck awkwardly. “Okay, that probably sounds weird, but it’s not what you think. It’s Natasha.”
My heart skipped a beat at the mention of her name. Natasha was a force, and I had seen her with Logan once or twice. They had a history. A messy history, from what I could gather, though I wasn’t sure of the specifics. But just the idea of her being involved made me feel uncomfortable. Jealous? Maybe. It wasn’t like I could even acknowledge that—couldn’t acknowledge that. Not when I had no claim on him.
“Natasha?” I echoed.
He nodded, looking somewhat apologetic. “Yeah. She’s been… persistent. You know how she can be. She’s been texting me non-stop, and I can’t seem to shake her off. So I thought maybe you could pretend to be my girlfriend for the evening. That way, she’ll get the hint.”
I felt a tightness in my chest, something like a mixture of panic and confusion. I wanted to refuse, to shut him down, but I couldn’t. Because somehow, some twisted part of me wanted to help him. Not just for him, but for me too. The thought of Natasha getting too close to him, of her lingering around, was too much.
I let out a shaky breath, my voice uncertain. “You want me to pretend to be your girlfriend?”
Logan leaned back in his seat, his expression earnest. “Yeah. Just for tonight. Nothing serious. But if you could help me out, I’d owe you one.”
A part of me screamed to say no. To walk away and pretend that this wasn’t my problem. But another part of me, the part that had been quietly hoping for something to change between us, wanted to say yes. To step into that role, to be the one to make Natasha back off. I swallowed hard.
“Okay,” I said, the word slipping out before I could stop myself. “I’ll help you.”
Logan’s eyes brightened, and he reached across the table, giving my hand a brief, friendly squeeze. “Thanks, Ava. Seriously. I appreciate it.”
We sat in silence for a moment, the weight of the decision settling between us. I shouldn’t have agreed to it. I knew that. But I also couldn’t shake the thought that this might be my only chance to spend time with Logan, to have him to myself for a few hours without the weight of expectations hanging over us. No tutors, no study guides, no academic pressure.
Just... us.
The night went smoother than I had expected. Logan was a natural at playing the role of a charming boyfriend, and I found myself falling into the routine of it far too easily. We joked, we laughed, we talked about everything and nothing all at once. Our chemistry was undeniable, the way our banter flowed so easily, as if we’d known each other for years.
It was terrifying how natural it felt to be close to him, to slip into this pretend world where I didn’t have to keep my distance, where I didn’t have to pretend I didn’t care. There were moments when his eyes lingered on mine, a softness in his gaze that made my breath catch in my throat. His smile, the way he’d touch his hair or rub his neck, all of it was so familiar, so comfortable, that I started to forget that this was a game. A pretense.
“You’re really good at this,” I said at one point, my voice teasing as I leaned across the table.
Logan raised an eyebrow, the corner of his lips curling up. “What, pretending to be a good boyfriend?”
I laughed, feeling a flush creep up my neck. “Well, I mean, you’re just so… charming.”
He chuckled, a low, amused sound that sent a small thrill down my spine. “I’m not pretending to be anything. This is just who I am.”
For a moment, I froze. My heart pounded against my chest, and I realized that I wasn’t just pretending either. No, the feeling in my chest wasn’t fake. The way my heart reacted to his words, the way it fluttered every time his fingers brushed against mine, was real.
This wasn’t just a game for me.
I had to pull myself together. I couldn’t let him see it. I couldn’t let him know that I was starting to fall for him, even if only in these stolen moments when we were together like this. That was the last thing I needed.
The rest of the evening passed in a blur of laughter and playful conversation. But inside, I was a mess. I couldn’t stop thinking about how easy it was to be around him, how I felt like I belonged in that moment, with him. And the more I tried to push those feelings away, the more they dug in, sinking deeper into my chest.
When we finally parted ways outside the diner, Logan flashed me that smile again—the one that made my heart do a little flip. “Thanks, Ava. You really helped me out tonight.”
I nodded, trying to keep my voice steady. “No problem.”
For a moment, we just stood there, the air between us thick with unspoken things. I felt his gaze on me, and I couldn’t look away. He was so close, too close. My chest was tight, my stomach a tangle of nerves.
“Well,” Logan said, finally breaking the silence. “I guess I’ll see you later right? I'm going out with the guys".
“Yeah,” I whispered.
He gave me a quick, casual hug, and I fought to ignore the way it made my skin tingle, how his scent lingered on me long after he pulled away. When he finally turned to walk toward his car, I felt my heart twist, a painful ache in my chest.
He wasn’t mine. I had no claim on him.
And yet, as I watched him disappear into the distance, I couldn’t shake the feeling that I wanted more. More of this, more of him. But I wasn’t ready to admit that not to him, and not to myself.
Not yet.