Chapter 14: Show me the proof!
Grace
“Heyy babe!” Abby exclaimed over the phone while I smiled and snuggled up the pillow.
“Good morning to you too,” I replied, waiting for her to tell me why she was calling so early in the morning.
“I know you’re wondering why I’m calling this early, right? Well, I have no reason at all, I just miss my best friend and I thought to call you.” She chimed in while I smirked and then laughed.
“You have no reason and you’re calling me at six in the morning. You’re so unbelievable, Abby! I know you’re dramatic but this is a new one.” I let out while she burst into laughter.
“Whatever rocks your boat baby. So tell me, how is the married life treating you?”
“Married life? Am I aware that I’m married because from where I’m standing I’m not married to anyone.” I retorted and she laughed again.
“Trust me, baby, you got married to Matt the second you took that ring from him. It’s only a matter of time now before I get to be the chief bridesmaid and I honestly can’t wait!” She screamed again and I had to pull the phone away from my ears. She was so loud.
“Hmmmmn… I’m not sure I want to do this, Anna. I don’t think I want to,” I slowly said while she immediately stopped laughing and went mute.
“What do you mean you’re not sure?” She whispered as if someone would hear her and get us in trouble.
“Why are you whispering? It’s not like Matt is there, or is he?” I teased while she scoffed.
“No baby, I don’t fuck dicks that already belong to other people and you’re even my sister so I can’t do that to you.” She joked and we both laughed it off.
It’s not like I would be so mad if she did that anyway but then, Matt isn’t even worth it so I don’t want him involved with my friend.
“What happened though? Did he do something? Did he cheat on you?” She asked.
“Cheat on me? Are we even talking about that? When has he ever not cheated on me? I don’t even see it as an offense anymore at this point and it’s not the reason why I’m changing my mind. I’ve just had a lot of thinking to do and I don’t think I want to spend the rest of my life where I don’t want to be.” I explained.
“That’s valid but this is coming off to me like you already have a replacement in mind.” She retorted and I wasn’t surprised at all. Abby is that one person who can see right through me. I can’t lie to her and I’ve never even tried to.
“Well, I won’t call it a replacement…”
“Just tell me who it is, Grace.” She cut in impatiently.
I opened my mouth to tell her but then stopped when I saw the door open. I immediately sat up and was surprised to see Matt stroll in.
“Grace… Grace…” Abby called out but I was too distracted to answer.
“Let me calm you back please,” I finally replied and then hung up.
“You look surprised to see me, why?” Matt asked.
“Well, I didn’t know you’d be coming back today, I wasn’t expecting you back so soon.” I replied while he shot me a suspicious look.
“And here I was thinking my dear fiancé would have missed me so much and probably even jump on me the second she sees me.” He countered while I then got up and went to give him a hug.
“Now that’s more like it. I also didn’t know I’d be coming back so soon but I missed you so much I couldn’t afford to spend another day without you.” He chimed in and I forced out a smile.
“Give me some minutes to freshen up, I’ll be right back,” he added and then vanished into the bathroom.
I sat at the edge of the bed, waiting for him to be done so we can finally have the long awaited conversation. I know it seems early since he just got back but better now than later when something comes up and ruins my plans.
I can’t let anything get in the way this time.
About ten minutes later, he finally came out and stark naked too. He had a naughty smirk on his face which made me look away, but he still came to me.
“Why are you looking away? Didn’t you just say it that you miss me?” He asked and then leaned over to kiss me but I pulled back.
I saw the anger rose in his eyes but he kept his cool and tried again. I moved back again and he angrily stood straight.
“What exactly is the matter with you? I can’t touch you or kiss you or fuck you?!” He fired at me.
“I never said you can’t, it’s just that I’m not in the mood right now.” I replied.
“Will you fucking stop with the lies? That’s your excuse every damn time. You’re never in the mood but you keep giving it out for free to the men out there!” He yelled at me while my heart immediately started beating so fast.
Matt has said lots of things to me but he has never questioned my loyalty to him. If he’s saying this, then the fire isn’t without smoke. He definitely knows something.
“What are you even saying right now? Giving what out to who? Are you seriously accusing me of cheating on you?” I asked, hoping I putting up the act so well.
“I’m not accusing you. I know you are doing it and you can’t even deny it because I have solid proof. You know I don’t do blind confrontations.” He said firmly and I almost passed out.
My eyes had turned blurry and my legs were starting to shake. My head was starting to work on overtime, trying to figure out what the proof could be. I couldn’t find anything but I knew for sure that he didn’t know about Theo.
There’s no way Matt would be this calm if he knew it’s his brother that I have my eyes on.
“I don’t know what you’re talking about, Matt. Can I see the proof then?” I asked, hoping he was only bluffing.
“You really want to keep this up right? Fine then, I’ll show you.” He said and then hurried to the desk. He grabbed his phone, scrolled for a long second before finally shoving the screen in my face.
I stared at the screen and froze immediately. It was a picture of Theo and I kissing!!!