Chapter 76: Chapter Thirty Three-2
"Oh, shit, I forgot." "Clearly," he frowns, his voice monotone. "Are you going to invite me in?" "I guess," I sigh, stepping back. "What did you want to talk about?" "Us." "There is no 'us'," I gesture between our bodies as we walk into the kitchen. "You made that decision." "What if I want to take it back?" "Oh for God's sake," I groan, turning away from him and going to the fridge. "You only want me because I'm with someone else." "You're not with Hayden." "Doesn't matter if I'm not technically dating him," I snap, pouring myself a juice and not offering him one. "I'm still loyal to him." "You had to settle because you couldn't get who you really wanted," Ashton insists, coming behind me. I feel the hair on the back of my neck bristle. "That is the stupidest thing I've ever heard you say." "I still affect you," he murmurs. "Look at the goosebumps on your skin." I whirl around and shove his chest, causing him to stumble back a few steps. Having him this close feels disrespectful to Hayden. "You're giving me the creeps, that's why." "Grace," he sighs. "I made some mistakes, okay? Give me a second chance. It's always been me and you. No one else stands a chance." "You're, like, 110% wrong," I say, looking at him like he is on drugs. "I really like Hayden. More than I liked you." "You're just saying that to try and hurt me." "No, you're just making me be brutally honest," I snap, growing more frustrated by the second. "And besides, I don't even know anything about you because you refused to let me in. You just wanted to have sex with me. What Hayden and I have is real. You don't understand because you don't want real with me. You don't want to date." He exhales deeply, sitting on the edge of the dining room table. He pinches the skin in between his eyes. "How can I fix this?" "You can't," I tell him honestly, hanging my head. "It's too late. I've fallen for Hayden." "So what happened between us really meant nothing?" his eyes meet mine and I am surprised to see they hold moisture. My stomach drops at the sad, hopeless look in his eyes. Considering I thought he was quite heartless, I am surprised he is showing this much emotion. "Ashton," I whisper, taking a step forward. I feel like I need to comfort him but I don't want to cross any lines. "Look, of course, it meant a lot to me. But I've moved on now and you need to respect that." "Is it because you don't know much about me? What do you want to know? I'll tell you anything." "There's no point, Ashton." "My name is Ashton Theodore Brennon. I'm 22 and have been the swim team captain of the Cobras for two years now. I have an older brother, I like to play the drums in my spare time, but only when I'm at my mate's house. My favourite colour is red and I love Italian food-" "Ashton, stop!" I exclaim, throwing my hands up in the air. "Look, you had the chance to do this with me a long time ago and you blew it. You said we couldn't date and you were right. I was infatuated at the time because you're attractive, older... I would have been crazy not to fall for you. You showed me interest and it was really flattering. But all it was, was hormones and lust. We were attracted to each other physically and it was wrong. You're my Coach. You're practically a teacher to me and I should have known better. But honestly, you should have known better, too. You're the older one. It's wrong and you know it. I'm being mature and moving on. Please do the same." "How can I, when I see you every day?" I shrug, letting out a sigh. "That's something you have to work out on your own." "Does he know?" "What?" "Does Hayden know?" I open my mouth and close it several times, my mind stuck. I am frozen as I scramble to come up with a reply. "I didn't think so," he remarks dryly, folding his well-built arms across his chest, the vulnerable look on his face transforming into something far more sinister. "What do you think he would do if he found out?" "He would probably be devastated because of what happened with Carrie," I reply honestly, not liking the tone he is using. This is something that has been preoccupying my mind for some time now. His eyes snap to mine. "You know about Carrie?" "I do," I nod, planting my hand on my hip. "Is that why you like me? Because I look like her?" "It is what drew me to you," he admits. "I'm very surprised he told you that." "We communicate with each other, like normal people, that's why," I point out. "But you haven't told him," he replies, a small smirk on his face. "Shame if he found out." "Don't come into my home and threaten me," I snap, glaring at him. I can't believe the words coming out of his mouth right now. He shrugs, pushing himself off the table, looking at me like he knows something I didn't. It is scary how fast his attitude changed. "I just said it would be a shame if he found out," he strides over to me, before he places his finger under my chin, tilting my head back to meet his eyes. He smirks down at me and I sneer up at him, wanting nothing more but to wipe that sadistic smirk off his face. "You do realise how pathetic you seem, right?" "Yeah," he says in a low voice, his lips mere millimetres from mine. His hot breath blasted my face. "I'm the pathetic one." I shove my chin out his hold and he grins as if he has won some sort of contest before he walks from me. "Oh and you still owe me detention," he throws over his shoulder. I stand there, breathless, my knees wobbling together as I hear the front door close. My screw shut as I clutch my shirt in my hand, my chest aching. This is it. Hayden is going to find out. And we will be done. --------------------