Chapter 11: Family Ties

Alison and Oliver decided to speak with the families of the three victims.

The afternoon heat of July had turned the asphalt scorching hot.

Alison followed Oliver out of the apartment building. About a dozen police officers assigned by the department were assisting at the scene. The family members had been separated into different patrol cars, each watched by two officers.

An older officer with graying hair at his temples and a stocky build was crouching beside a police car with a bent front bumper, smoking a cigarette. He casually waved at them as they approached. Oliver greeted him familiarly, "Allan."

"Haven't seen you in a while. Heard you and your girlfriend went on vacation abroad? We're drowning in cases here, and you're living the good life." Allan Saunders joked with no trace of actual jealousy in his voice. His eyes landed on Alison as he asked Oliver, "New team member?"

"This is Alison, psychological analyst and religious studies expert, temporarily assisting us with the case." Oliver teased back, "All you guys do is catch petty thieves. What big cases could you possibly have?"

Allan protested, "That's not true! Not long ago, we had a missing female teacher case—daughter of some big professor. All police forces were mobilized, and the department's K-9 units lost at least a few pounds from the search."

Alison remained expressionless as she continued to listen to their small talk, planning to find an opportunity to question Allan privately later.

Oliver said, "Enough chitchat. Let's get to business."

Allan put away his jovial expression and flipped open his notebook. "Received the call at 1:16 PM. The caller was Byron's neighbor, an elderly woman. She was hiding behind her door watching the whole argument. Her testimony matches the others—Hannah was the only one who got physical, pushing Byron several times with considerable force."

Hannah was Linda's mother.

Oliver flipped through the statements. "Why isn't there a statement from Hannah?"

Saunders replied, "Hannah refuses to cooperate. Won't say a word."

Alison turned to the police car parked in the shade. The rear window was halfway down. Hannah, nearly seventy, sat hunched with disheveled gray hair hanging loosely around her face, her eyes vacant.

Helen sat beside her, speaking in a gentle voice, but Hannah silently refused to cooperate.

Noticing Alison's gaze, Helen pressed her slightly dry lips together.

The last time Alison had accompanied Oliver as a psychological analyst to interview Byron, that had been Helen's job. Taylor, Susan, and Manuel had all praised Alison's performance that day.

"Why did you push Byron? Was it intentional or an accident?" Helen couldn't help raising her voice. "Hannah, stop wasting our time!"

Oliver knocked on the window twice. "Helen, get out."

His expression remained calm. Helen wasn't sure if Oliver had noticed her loss of composure. After exiting the car, she tried to appear collected. "Mr. West, Hannah has a history of acute heart attacks. I wouldn't recommend using aggressive questioning techniques that might agitate her."

Oliver acknowledged with a nod and got into the car.

Alison stood by the door and glanced at Helen's face. "Are you feeling irritable? Maybe heat stroke?"

"Perhaps," Helen smiled weakly. She had messed up something as simple as taking a statement, and now she was anxious that Oliver would blame her.

She handed the notebook to Alison. "I'll go take a break."

Inside the car, Oliver got straight to the point. "The hospital says Byron died from a skull fracture with intracranial bleeding. It was your push that caused the fatal injury. According to eyewitnesses, you repeatedly pushed and hit Byron during the argument. Don't you want to defend yourself? The sentence for intentional homicide is much heavier than for manslaughter."

"It doesn't matter," Hannah croaked.

Oliver signaled to Alison that the next part didn't need to be recorded in the statement, then said to Hannah, "I understand the pain of losing your daughter."

"You don't understand! After all this time, you still haven't caught the real killer!" Hannah's emotions flared. "Byron was the one who targeted my innocent child for fame! He deserved to die!"

She sobbed loudly, "My daughter had such a hard life. Her father died early, and after just a few years of marriage, she became a widow like me. I always worried about how she'd live alone after I'm gone, but who knew she would die before me!"

"My daughter never did anything wrong, yet she was hung up like that—dying in such an undignified way!" Hannah's swollen eyes revealed intense hatred.

Oliver silently watched her cry.

A crowd of onlookers had gathered beyond the police line, their murmurs drifting over. Alison poked Oliver's shoulder with her pen. "Aren't you going to tell her to stop crying?"

"I can't," Oliver stepped out of the car, clearly irritated. "You try, or call Lillian."

Alison leaned into the car, holding onto the roof. "If you go to prison, there will be no one left in this world who cares about finding out the truth about your daughter's death."

This statement made Hannah even more distraught, but her anger subsided somewhat.

Alison handed her tissues. "To be honest, Byron was connected to your daughter's death, but he didn't kill her. Do you want the real murderer to go free?"

Hannah shook her head.

Seeing that she was listening, Alison breathed a sigh of relief. "Why are you so convinced Byron harmed your daughter?"

"I saw the criminal case expert's video," Hannah replied between sobs.

"That guy isn't a real police officer." Alison looked toward Oliver. "You didn't shut down that fake expert's account?"

"The videos were taken down, but they spread too widely," Oliver replied glumly, not wanting to discuss the topic. Online commenters were accusing the police of "silencing" people and protecting Byron.

He asked Hannah, "Who arranged for all of you to meet today?"

Hannah answered, "Amanda."

Amanda was Quincy's fiancée.

Just then, Lillian came over with three bottles of water. Oliver asked her to stay with Hannah to keep her calm, while he and Alison walked to another car where Amanda was waiting.

Amanda, forty-six, had a voluptuous figure and wore a tight-fitting dress. Heavy makeup concealed her true features. Bored with waiting, she had killed several mosquitoes.

"I've told you everything I know. Why can't I leave?" Amanda tried to exit the car but was pushed back by an officer. She shouted, "Police brutality!"

"Shut up!" Oliver snapped at her.

Amanda hadn't expected such a handsome police officer. She flashed him a playful smile and teased, "If it were you wanting to get physical with me, I definitely wouldn't scream or struggle."

Oliver's face instantly darkened.

Alison couldn't help but laugh.

"Why did you gather the families to confront Byron?" Oliver asked.

"Byron killed someone. Can't we settle the score with him?" Amanda said self-righteously.

Oliver asked sternly, "Do you have evidence that Byron committed murder? For justice, there are police and judges. You deliberately caused a disturbance that interfered with police work. You'll also be held responsible for Byron's death!"

"That's unfair!" Amanda wailed dramatically. "I don't even have a job. Quincy died without leaving me a penny. How am I supposed to live? I just wanted compensation. Hannah killed him, not me!"

Oliver smirked. "You wanted to extort money? You have a record, don't you? Multiple counts of romance fraud."

"How can matters of the heart be called fraud? I slept with those men, they gave me money—it was consensual." After saying this, Amanda shrank back, frightened by the anger in Oliver's eyes.

Oliver spoke harshly, "Women like you—"

Alison interrupted him and asked, "Were you seeing other men while you were with Quincy?"

Oliver closed his eyes briefly, regaining his composure a moment later.

"Yes," Amanda answered hesitantly.

Alison asked, "Did Quincy know?"

Amanda replied, "He probably did. Last month, I was having an affair at home with someone when Quincy came back unexpectedly."

Alison pressed, "How did Quincy react?"

Amanda scoffed, "That coward? How do you think he reacted?"

After Alison finished with Amanda, there was one more family member to interview. Walking the several dozen yards to the next car, Alison casually asked Oliver, "Have you ever been deceived in a relationship?"

Amanda's words had clearly triggered an emotional response in Oliver, revealing something to her.

"No," Oliver denied immediately.

"I see," Alison nodded knowingly.

"What do you see?" Oliver narrowed his eyes slightly, showing a mix of agitation and embarrassment.

"Someone as smart as you wouldn't get fooled," Alison tactfully didn't press the issue, though inwardly she was surprised that Oliver had apparently once been played by a woman.